Zürcher Nachrichten - Ukraine prosecutor probes war crimes in fog of war

EUR -
AED 3.849023
AFN 71.377105
ALL 98.713018
AMD 408.027217
ANG 1.888169
AOA 956.757159
ARS 1045.773778
AUD 1.6014
AWG 1.888888
AZN 1.790592
BAM 1.967019
BBD 2.115265
BDT 125.194055
BGN 1.966739
BHD 0.394852
BIF 3094.650597
BMD 1.047927
BND 1.412054
BOB 7.23929
BRL 6.078989
BSD 1.047676
BTN 88.429063
BWP 14.312633
BYN 3.428555
BYR 20539.367995
BZD 2.111745
CAD 1.460103
CDF 3008.598175
CHF 0.933105
CLF 0.03714
CLP 1024.7943
CNY 7.590121
CNH 7.588128
COP 4600.137266
CRC 533.643681
CUC 1.047927
CUP 27.770064
CVE 110.897513
CZK 25.354598
DJF 186.564084
DKK 7.458169
DOP 63.140125
DZD 140.654233
EGP 51.730874
ERN 15.718904
ETB 128.254711
FJD 2.385029
FKP 0.827147
GBP 0.832195
GEL 2.871238
GGP 0.827147
GHS 16.552408
GIP 0.827147
GMD 74.40309
GNF 9030.506244
GTQ 8.087126
GYD 219.180112
HKD 8.156576
HNL 26.475002
HRK 7.475134
HTG 137.524382
HUF 411.442327
IDR 16707.675541
ILS 3.888244
IMP 0.827147
INR 88.48302
IQD 1372.427756
IRR 44091.525793
ISK 146.374379
JEP 0.827147
JMD 166.901939
JOD 0.743084
JPY 161.400652
KES 135.673827
KGS 90.645742
KHR 4218.058045
KMF 495.144769
KPW 943.133847
KRW 1471.823666
KWD 0.322605
KYD 0.87308
KZT 523.103565
LAK 23012.252297
LBP 93817.093604
LKR 304.919132
LRD 189.098539
LSL 18.905328
LTL 3.094256
LVL 0.633881
LYD 5.116181
MAD 10.539412
MDL 19.10899
MGA 4889.889894
MKD 61.882955
MMK 3403.625819
MNT 3560.855681
MOP 8.399809
MRU 41.685758
MUR 49.095582
MVR 16.200603
MWK 1816.66148
MXN 21.338895
MYR 4.68214
MZN 66.973076
NAD 18.905328
NGN 1778.018417
NIO 38.549872
NOK 11.531786
NPR 141.486983
NZD 1.787143
OMR 0.40329
PAB 1.047676
PEN 3.972658
PGK 4.218058
PHP 61.763748
PKR 290.932457
PLN 4.335792
PYG 8178.647597
QAR 3.820792
RON 5.009395
RSD 117.676176
RUB 108.684182
RWF 1430.15702
SAR 3.934367
SBD 8.785353
SCR 14.355505
SDG 630.325516
SEK 11.490398
SGD 1.407224
SHP 0.827147
SLE 23.819044
SLL 21974.508901
SOS 598.71482
SRD 37.195159
STD 21689.971872
SVC 9.167286
SYP 2632.947722
SZL 18.898791
THB 36.095812
TJS 11.157437
TMT 3.667744
TND 3.328384
TOP 2.454353
TRY 36.229795
TTD 7.115584
TWD 34.145125
TZS 2786.794716
UAH 43.342206
UGX 3871.079021
USD 1.047927
UYU 44.554118
UZS 13440.659923
VES 48.790577
VND 26637.254851
VUV 124.411992
WST 2.925383
XAF 659.719767
XAG 0.033387
XAU 0.000385
XCD 2.832075
XDR 0.796945
XOF 659.719767
XPF 119.331742
YER 261.90314
ZAR 18.881343
ZMK 9432.600526
ZMW 28.941068
ZWL 337.432047
  • SCS

    0.2300

    13.27

    +1.73%

  • GSK

    0.2600

    33.96

    +0.77%

  • AZN

    1.3700

    65.63

    +2.09%

  • CMSC

    0.0320

    24.672

    +0.13%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    6.79

    -0.15%

  • NGG

    1.0296

    63.11

    +1.63%

  • CMSD

    0.0150

    24.46

    +0.06%

  • BTI

    0.4000

    37.38

    +1.07%

  • BCE

    0.0900

    26.77

    +0.34%

  • RIO

    -0.2200

    62.35

    -0.35%

  • BCC

    3.4200

    143.78

    +2.38%

  • RBGPF

    59.2400

    59.24

    +100%

  • VOD

    0.1323

    8.73

    +1.52%

  • RELX

    0.9900

    46.75

    +2.12%

  • BP

    0.2000

    29.72

    +0.67%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.21

    -0.15%

Ukraine prosecutor probes war crimes in fog of war
Ukraine prosecutor probes war crimes in fog of war

Ukraine prosecutor probes war crimes in fog of war

US President Joe Biden has called his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin a "war criminal". But it is the job of Iryna Venediktova, Ukraine's prosecutor general, to make the case.

Text size:

"Yes, we can prove it," Venediktova told AFP.

"I'd even say more. He is the main war criminal of the 21st century."

Venediktova is investigating and tallying the mounting cases of suspected crimes by Putin's invading forces.

The 43-year-old shuffles a grim sheaf of printouts: a maternity hospital wrecked by shelling; a burnt-out theatre that was sheltering children; and an ash-covered street strewn with the rubble of apartment buildings.

These are just a few of the cases she is building against Russia's commanders, ministers and Putin himself.

"He actually wants to destroy Ukraine as a state," she said, speaking from the western city of Lviv -- for security reasons, she asked AFP not to reveal her exact location.

- 'The judicial front' -

Atrocities committed in the fog of war often remain hidden from justice forever. Investigations are rare and can take years, if ever, to come to fruition.

But Ukraine is making a major effort on what Venediktova calls "the judicial front" to be "successful in the nearest future".

"Time flies very, very fast in war," she says.

As of Wednesday midday the prosecutor's office had recorded 2,401 "crimes of aggression and war crimes" and 1,516 "crimes against national security" in the first month of conflict.

There are 127 "wanted" suspects in what Venediktova calls the "anchor case" against Russia's civil and military regime.

Since the invasion began on February 24 Venediktova has been travelling the length and breadth of unoccupied Ukraine gathering evidence.

There are "before and after" satellite images of flattened buildings, interviews with captured Russian soldiers, and the testimony of refugees fleeing across the border.

"I try to be in the place where I need to be," she says.

The crimes she identifies vary enormously. There are "a lot" of cases of wartime rape; there is the indiscriminate shelling of civilian buildings; and a child who died of dehydration in a blockaded city.

The besieged port city of Mariupol is foremost in her mind. "I try to be a very cold prosecutor," she says.

"What now I see in Mariupol it's not about war, it's about genocide.

"Theatres of war have some rules, some principles. What we see in Mariupol, [are] no rules at all."

The city has been taken hostage, she says. "It's impossible to give them food, water, electricity -- and the Russian Federation exactly knows what they are doing here."

But the most upsetting case she has considered so far is of a 14 year-old boy reportedly killed in a Russian tank attack on the fourth day of the war.

On a mobile phone she shows a graphic photo of a munition round lodged in his open chest.

That, for her, was "the most powerful" case, she said, her voice trailing off.

The prosecutor's running tally shows 121 children killed so far in the war.

- Pursuing an international prosecution -

Ukraine may feel its case against Russia is strong, but the prospect of seeing meaningful justice will be complex.

Venediktova says cases will be prosecuted in Ukraine's domestic courts. But the highest prize would be conviction in an international court.

Ukraine is not a member of the International Criminal Court (ICC) but it has accepted its jurisdiction in the past, leaving the door open to a tribunal.

ICC prosecutor Karim Khan has opened an investigation after 41 other member states referred Ukraine's case to his office.

"There is a reasonable basis to believe that both alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity have been committed," he said earlier this month.

However, because Russia is not an ICC member it cannot adjudicate on the more straightforward case of "crimes of aggression".

The ICC also does not conduct trials in absentia, and the prospect of seeing Russian suspects transported from the pariah state to the dock at the Hague seems remote.

Venediktova is optimistic, however.

She believes there is a strong case for Russia to face charges of war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide at the ICC.

Her team is collecting evidence so Khan's prosecution "will be successful" if and when Ukraine has its day in court.

"Nobody knows what will be in the future," she says.

A.Weber--NZN