Zürcher Nachrichten - Disgraced windpipe surgeon convicted in Sweden for harming patient

EUR -
AED 3.857576
AFN 71.468972
ALL 97.945793
AMD 407.899953
ANG 1.887325
AOA 956.768148
ARS 1057.642257
AUD 1.623854
AWG 1.890468
AZN 1.788374
BAM 1.948121
BBD 2.114316
BDT 125.13675
BGN 1.956264
BHD 0.395904
BIF 3093.646897
BMD 1.05026
BND 1.410015
BOB 7.236613
BRL 6.086888
BSD 1.047143
BTN 88.269389
BWP 14.286957
BYN 3.427026
BYR 20585.099959
BZD 2.1109
CAD 1.478777
CDF 3014.246506
CHF 0.931683
CLF 0.037139
CLP 1024.68611
CNY 7.622996
CNH 7.6248
COP 4616.901837
CRC 535.075615
CUC 1.05026
CUP 27.831895
CVE 109.832076
CZK 25.287322
DJF 186.471437
DKK 7.458365
DOP 63.129959
DZD 140.333108
EGP 52.114124
ERN 15.753903
ETB 131.046404
FJD 2.39251
FKP 0.828988
GBP 0.835675
GEL 2.86709
GGP 0.828988
GHS 16.441506
GIP 0.828988
GMD 74.568531
GNF 9023.432445
GTQ 8.081989
GYD 219.082274
HKD 8.173303
HNL 26.485853
HRK 7.491778
HTG 137.43761
HUF 410.914351
IDR 16702.287992
ILS 3.828004
IMP 0.828988
INR 88.518455
IQD 1371.766801
IRR 44202.828808
ISK 145.292953
JEP 0.828988
JMD 165.35821
JOD 0.744952
JPY 161.284236
KES 135.609646
KGS 91.188878
KHR 4203.511118
KMF 492.519883
KPW 945.233784
KRW 1465.296775
KWD 0.323154
KYD 0.872677
KZT 522.869056
LAK 22915.8909
LBP 93777.451442
LKR 304.942206
LRD 187.97265
LSL 18.94897
LTL 3.101146
LVL 0.635292
LYD 5.123852
MAD 10.497821
MDL 19.137929
MGA 4889.7726
MKD 61.580453
MMK 3411.204168
MNT 3568.78411
MOP 8.394073
MRU 41.652612
MUR 49.697925
MVR 16.226408
MWK 1815.808073
MXN 21.646283
MYR 4.681534
MZN 67.108241
NAD 18.94879
NGN 1767.488579
NIO 38.538826
NOK 11.70715
NPR 141.230624
NZD 1.801764
OMR 0.404321
PAB 1.047182
PEN 3.951699
PGK 4.221221
PHP 61.928612
PKR 290.958293
PLN 4.311904
PYG 8171.944362
QAR 3.81815
RON 4.976978
RSD 116.981145
RUB 111.60666
RWF 1442.84025
SAR 3.945668
SBD 8.812303
SCR 14.282519
SDG 631.731822
SEK 11.533406
SGD 1.415119
SHP 0.828988
SLE 23.84048
SLL 22023.436279
SOS 598.452483
SRD 37.184471
STD 21738.265714
SVC 9.162883
SYP 2638.810116
SZL 18.953929
THB 36.476031
TJS 11.189401
TMT 3.686413
TND 3.309219
TOP 2.459814
TRY 36.391337
TTD 7.120003
TWD 34.110145
TZS 2777.9378
UAH 43.509997
UGX 3879.7442
USD 1.05026
UYU 44.624106
UZS 13419.360611
VES 48.925574
VND 26692.363033
VUV 124.689002
WST 2.931897
XAF 653.393967
XAG 0.034536
XAU 0.0004
XCD 2.838381
XDR 0.801027
XOF 653.381574
XPF 119.331742
YER 262.486264
ZAR 19.109062
ZMK 9453.602349
ZMW 28.876453
ZWL 338.183357
  • NGG

    -0.6600

    62.6

    -1.05%

  • RYCEF

    0.0300

    6.8

    +0.44%

  • RIO

    -1.0350

    61.945

    -1.67%

  • CMSC

    -0.1600

    24.57

    -0.65%

  • RBGPF

    0.8100

    61

    +1.33%

  • GSK

    -0.2400

    33.91

    -0.71%

  • SCS

    -0.1500

    13.57

    -1.11%

  • VOD

    -0.0300

    8.88

    -0.34%

  • BTI

    0.2150

    37.545

    +0.57%

  • RELX

    0.2700

    46.84

    +0.58%

  • BCC

    -3.8200

    148.68

    -2.57%

  • AZN

    -0.3100

    66.09

    -0.47%

  • BCE

    -0.3350

    26.685

    -1.26%

  • BP

    -0.4200

    28.9

    -1.45%

  • CMSD

    -0.1050

    24.475

    -0.43%

  • JRI

    -0.0910

    13.279

    -0.69%

Disgraced windpipe surgeon convicted in Sweden for harming patient
Disgraced windpipe surgeon convicted in Sweden for harming patient / Photo: Karolinska University Hospital - KAROLINSKA UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL/AFP

Disgraced windpipe surgeon convicted in Sweden for harming patient

A Swedish court on Thursday found an Italian surgeon, once hailed for pioneering windpipe surgery, guilty of causing bodily harm to a patient, but cleared him of assault charges.

Text size:

Paolo Macchiarini won praise in 2011 after claiming to have performed the world's first synthetic trachea transplants using stem cells, while he was a surgeon at Stockholm's Karolinska University Hospital.

The experimental procedure was hailed as a breakthrough in regenerative medicine.

But allegations soon emerged that the procedure had been carried out on at least one person who had not been critically ill at the time of the surgery.

During the May trial held in the Solna district court, prosecutors argued that the surgeries on three patients in Sweden constituted assault, or alternatively bodily harm due to negligence, as Macchiarini disregarded "science and proven experience".

The district court agreed with the prosecutors that the procedures were not consistent with "science and proven experience," but cleared Macchiarini on two counts as the patients' health was in such a dire state.

"Given the patients' condition the district court finds that the procedures on the first two patients were justifiable," it said in a statement.

However, in the case of the third patient, the court found him guilty of "causing bodily harm".

"At the time of the procedure of the third patient, the experience from the first procedures was such that the surgeon should have refrained from letting yet another patient go through the operation," the court said.

Macchiarini was handed a suspended sentence, which in Sweden means that if he were to commit another crime during a two-year probation period, the court would re-evaluate his sentence.

- 'Plan B' -

Together with his colleagues, Macchiarini, 63, performed a total of eight such transplants between 2011 and 2014 -- three in Sweden in 2011 and 2012, and five in Russia.

The three patients in Sweden died, though the deaths have not been directly linked to the surgeries. Four of the five Russian patients have also died, according to Swedish media reports.

Macchiarini himself insisted in court that the transplants were an alternative decided upon after all other options had been excluded -- what he referred to as a "Plan B".

His lawyer, Bjorn Hurtig, meanwhile insisted that the surgeries were the result of "teamwork" and had been discussed with other senior colleagues.

Following Thursday's ruling, Hurtig said that while his client had hoped to be cleared on all counts, the court had acquitted him on "significant parts".

"We won most of the case", he told AFP.

Chief prosecutor Jim Westerberg meanwhile said his team had not expected the verdict.

It was "a surprise to us" that the court leaned heavily on the notion that the patients' dire health conditions justified drastic measures.

Neither side had decided whether to appeal the court's ruling.

Macchiarini was also employed by the Karolinska Institute research facility, which awards the Nobel Medicine Prize. An external review in 2015 found Macchiarini guilty of research misconduct.

Even though the Institute sacked him in 2016, it repeatedly defended him until 2018, when its own review found him and several other researchers guilty of scientific misconduct.

The university's principal and several others stepped down over the scandal.

Medical journal The Lancet in 2018 retracted two papers authored by Macchiarini.

In 2013, the Karolinska Hospital suspended all trachea transplants and refused to extend Macchiarini's contract as a surgeon.

H.Roth--NZN