Zürcher Nachrichten - Antakya's quake victims doubt Erdogan's rebuilding pledge

EUR -
AED 3.889183
AFN 71.737571
ALL 98.132997
AMD 409.225232
ANG 1.899671
AOA 964.599267
ARS 1057.242735
AUD 1.628259
AWG 1.900647
AZN 1.794683
BAM 1.955443
BBD 2.128312
BDT 125.956987
BGN 1.955461
BHD 0.399131
BIF 3112.860661
BMD 1.058857
BND 1.417054
BOB 7.283669
BRL 6.082285
BSD 1.054057
BTN 88.945449
BWP 14.380508
BYN 3.449002
BYR 20753.5882
BZD 2.124712
CAD 1.484088
CDF 3033.62413
CHF 0.936432
CLF 0.03737
CLP 1031.146428
CNY 7.663266
CNH 7.659053
COP 4663.087732
CRC 536.806992
CUC 1.058857
CUP 28.059698
CVE 110.244858
CZK 25.29501
DJF 187.704569
DKK 7.459216
DOP 63.508996
DZD 141.267524
EGP 52.372947
ERN 15.882848
ETB 130.479893
FJD 2.402755
FKP 0.835773
GBP 0.835965
GEL 2.895998
GGP 0.835773
GHS 16.811928
GIP 0.835773
GMD 75.178395
GNF 9083.426191
GTQ 8.143512
GYD 220.51971
HKD 8.242309
HNL 26.625387
HRK 7.553098
HTG 138.466009
HUF 406.533113
IDR 16770.699322
ILS 3.959404
IMP 0.835773
INR 89.367811
IQD 1380.912907
IRR 44583.154415
ISK 144.501697
JEP 0.835773
JMD 167.291015
JOD 0.750839
JPY 163.876581
KES 136.761754
KGS 91.596627
KHR 4259.262033
KMF 494.035988
KPW 952.970485
KRW 1475.569683
KWD 0.32563
KYD 0.878348
KZT 525.928877
LAK 23156.987783
LBP 94390.645726
LKR 307.096792
LRD 193.423794
LSL 19.089593
LTL 3.126528
LVL 0.640492
LYD 5.148302
MAD 10.553472
MDL 19.152682
MGA 4927.146315
MKD 61.523759
MMK 3439.124741
MNT 3597.994469
MOP 8.451855
MRU 42.025719
MUR 49.23062
MVR 16.358998
MWK 1827.783315
MXN 21.481182
MYR 4.744204
MZN 67.654933
NAD 19.089593
NGN 1766.204789
NIO 38.793279
NOK 11.664231
NPR 142.307344
NZD 1.799018
OMR 0.407745
PAB 1.054007
PEN 4.006468
PGK 4.240265
PHP 62.134004
PKR 292.816466
PLN 4.313576
PYG 8215.886871
QAR 3.844098
RON 4.975673
RSD 116.980344
RUB 105.624971
RWF 1447.949126
SAR 3.975036
SBD 8.88425
SCR 14.356313
SDG 636.917254
SEK 11.573079
SGD 1.41828
SHP 0.835773
SLE 23.958456
SLL 22203.697248
SOS 602.395628
SRD 37.488815
STD 21916.192572
SVC 9.223402
SYP 2660.408674
SZL 19.082694
THB 36.604709
TJS 11.21558
TMT 3.716586
TND 3.331491
TOP 2.479945
TRY 36.641203
TTD 7.15576
TWD 34.400131
TZS 2803.814207
UAH 43.653736
UGX 3870.292875
USD 1.058857
UYU 45.201741
UZS 13505.170252
VES 48.421804
VND 26910.838985
VUV 125.709576
WST 2.955894
XAF 655.843368
XAG 0.033979
XAU 0.000406
XCD 2.861613
XDR 0.801861
XOF 655.86814
XPF 119.331742
YER 264.581812
ZAR 19.005095
ZMK 9530.97796
ZMW 29.067062
ZWL 340.951374
  • CMSC

    0.1100

    24.68

    +0.45%

  • GSK

    0.3800

    33.73

    +1.13%

  • SCS

    0.0250

    13.255

    +0.19%

  • RBGPF

    1.6500

    61.84

    +2.67%

  • BCE

    0.3300

    27.15

    +1.22%

  • RYCEF

    0.0700

    6.85

    +1.02%

  • BCC

    1.0450

    141.135

    +0.74%

  • RIO

    1.2100

    62.19

    +1.95%

  • VOD

    0.1550

    8.925

    +1.74%

  • CMSD

    -0.0200

    24.42

    -0.08%

  • JRI

    0.1100

    13.21

    +0.83%

  • BP

    0.5150

    29.495

    +1.75%

  • NGG

    0.1400

    62.89

    +0.22%

  • BTI

    0.2850

    36.675

    +0.78%

  • RELX

    0.6700

    45.12

    +1.48%

  • AZN

    0.3050

    63.535

    +0.48%

Antakya's quake victims doubt Erdogan's rebuilding pledge
Antakya's quake victims doubt Erdogan's rebuilding pledge / Photo: OZAN KOSE - AFP

Antakya's quake victims doubt Erdogan's rebuilding pledge

Retired construction worker Ali Cimen looked at the pile of rubble raising dust over his former neighbourhood and scoffed at the idea that Turkey's earthquake disaster zone could be rebuilt in a year.

Text size:

Half a dozen growling excavators were levelling what was left of the 60-year-old apartment complex in the ancient Syria-border city of Antakya.

Hundreds more swung their giant arms and raised a cacophony of noise across this mountain-ringed melting pot of ancient civilisation.

Antakya was known as Antioch until it became part of Turkey and inherited the mantle of one of the region's most free-spirited cities.

Its skeletal remains -- precariously standing since a 7.8-magnitude quake unleashed its devastation exactly two months ago -- were now being turned to rubble and dust.

What comes in their place -- and when -- is a matter of intense social and political debate.

"I don't think the reconstruction can be accomplished in a year," Cimen said, while watching his home being torn down.

"Maybe somewhere else. But here, under these conditions, removing the rubble alone will take at least a year."

- Election pledges -

Antakya bore the brunt of a calamity that claimed more than 50,000 lives and tested the leadership of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan ahead of May 14 elections.

Erdogan has made a bold campaign pledge to rebuild the entire disaster zone -- originally home to more than 13 million people -- by the start of next year.

Few of those who remain in the hollowed shell of this city believe him.

The stench of decomposing bodies wafts in with the wind from piles of uninspected rubble and random street corners.

Lines of hanging laundry betray signs of life persevering in all the emptiness and ruin.

Patches of the old city centre -- once a vibrant maze of romantic cafes and boutique shops -- remain impassable because of metres-high mounds of debris.

Erdogan told the nation on Wednesday that half the rubble had already been cleared from Antakya's Hatay province.

Retiree Gokhan Karaoglan treated Erdogan's pledges with a healthy dose of scorn.

"It's been two months and they still haven't cleared the rubble," the 54-year-old said.

"It will take another three, four or five years. Meanwhile, we live in misery."

- Tearing it all down -

The chief engineer at the demolition site said workers were under orders to raze buildings most liable to collapse first.

"Even the buildings you still see standing are damaged will eventually be torn down," Murat Sirma said.

"I think very few buildings will remain when this is all over," said the 45-year-old.

"Maybe five or 10 percent of them."

It is hazardous work. The dust is intermixed with cement and poisonous material such as asbestos -- an insulant linked to cancer.

Huge chunks of buildings often come crashing down in a tidal wave that covers the entire site in tall plumes of noxious dust.

The workers tend to wear face masks. Locals who gather to watch the destruction do not.

"There are 1,000 excavators working in Hatay," Sirma said. "That's a huge amount of work."

- 'The living dead' -

Heavy lorries piled high with the rubble clog that city's outer roads.

They trundle towards one of a handful of government-designated landfills that are then doused with water to keep down the dust.

Many in Antakya appear so subsumed by shock and grief that they fail to clearly visualise a future that comes after all the debris is removed.

Turkey's record of rebuilding historic cities is blemished by the example of Diyarbakir -- a mostly Kurdish city whose twice-reconstructed old town lacks much of the original's charm.

Engineer Sirma said the new plans for Antakya's construction would be laid down once all the rubble is removed.

Emina Burc could not think that far ahead.

The 39-year-old divorcee joined a handful of others to watch excavators tear down the remains of her home.

"To be honest, I feel like we're the living dead," she said.

But Karaoglan said he was clinging on to hope.

"This is where I was born, this is where I built my home, and this is where I will eventually die," he said.

P.E.Steiner--NZN