Zürcher Nachrichten - Survivors wait for aid as Trump's lies help cloud Helene response

EUR -
AED 4.034832
AFN 75.153588
ALL 98.781004
AMD 423.940779
ANG 1.97682
AOA 1002.393926
ARS 1070.743225
AUD 1.629334
AWG 1.9787
AZN 1.864354
BAM 1.956432
BBD 2.214705
BDT 131.072332
BGN 1.956861
BHD 0.414106
BIF 3191.301643
BMD 1.098515
BND 1.430455
BOB 7.595419
BRL 6.037107
BSD 1.096849
BTN 92.110587
BWP 14.508554
BYN 3.589038
BYR 21530.889829
BZD 2.211004
CAD 1.495886
CDF 3158.230029
CHF 0.937456
CLF 0.03688
CLP 1017.631331
CNY 7.768584
CNH 7.767818
COP 4629.690571
CRC 570.379023
CUC 1.098515
CUP 29.110642
CVE 110.300624
CZK 25.370142
DJF 195.322194
DKK 7.455728
DOP 66.240791
DZD 145.973965
EGP 53.168006
ERN 16.477722
ETB 131.038729
FJD 2.437384
FKP 0.836584
GBP 0.838672
GEL 3.015455
GGP 0.836584
GHS 17.385536
GIP 0.836584
GMD 75.797467
GNF 9466.971367
GTQ 8.487819
GYD 229.38304
HKD 8.53479
HNL 27.274561
HRK 7.468814
HTG 144.646058
HUF 402.221
IDR 17229.655179
ILS 4.170066
IMP 0.836584
INR 92.252396
IQD 1436.85098
IRR 46233.740873
ISK 148.497533
JEP 0.836584
JMD 173.424432
JOD 0.77852
JPY 162.315496
KES 141.50011
KGS 93.044256
KHR 4462.420916
KMF 492.459826
KPW 988.662686
KRW 1480.457671
KWD 0.336607
KYD 0.914087
KZT 531.886942
LAK 23952.736012
LBP 98208.53217
LKR 321.823939
LRD 211.696444
LSL 19.094367
LTL 3.243629
LVL 0.664481
LYD 5.230666
MAD 10.777732
MDL 19.268891
MGA 5041.582385
MKD 61.550159
MMK 3567.933178
MNT 3732.753198
MOP 8.775374
MRU 43.414626
MUR 51.168559
MVR 16.862164
MWK 1901.996973
MXN 21.222839
MYR 4.710432
MZN 70.195327
NAD 19.094193
NGN 1778.286807
NIO 40.362668
NOK 11.706471
NPR 147.374256
NZD 1.791285
OMR 0.422958
PAB 1.096849
PEN 4.086138
PGK 4.370372
PHP 62.457704
PKR 304.545787
PLN 4.322916
PYG 8551.723025
QAR 3.998091
RON 4.978905
RSD 117.034692
RUB 105.672813
RWF 1487.666929
SAR 4.126122
SBD 9.094289
SCR 16.489433
SDG 660.757344
SEK 11.369469
SGD 1.431513
SHP 0.836584
SLE 25.0981
SLL 23035.300181
SOS 626.896762
SRD 34.581797
STD 22737.038202
SVC 9.598012
SYP 2760.051288
SZL 19.08399
THB 36.829355
TJS 11.670663
TMT 3.855787
TND 3.371789
TOP 2.572828
TRY 37.647013
TTD 7.438335
TWD 35.37487
TZS 2993.45274
UAH 45.191984
UGX 4031.283634
USD 1.098515
UYU 45.725184
UZS 14012.589424
VEF 3979427.526393
VES 40.637912
VND 27292.599887
VUV 130.417882
WST 3.073054
XAF 656.162948
XAG 0.035012
XAU 0.000416
XCD 2.968791
XDR 0.815956
XOF 656.165935
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.952836
ZAR 19.156653
ZMK 9887.953249
ZMW 29.072257
ZWL 353.721313
  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    6.87

    -0.15%

  • CMSC

    -0.1300

    24.57

    -0.53%

  • RBGPF

    60.5200

    60.52

    +100%

  • GSK

    -0.1900

    38.63

    -0.49%

  • NGG

    -1.0200

    65.48

    -1.56%

  • RIO

    -0.0800

    69.62

    -0.11%

  • BTI

    -0.0900

    35.2

    -0.26%

  • BCC

    2.3700

    141.27

    +1.68%

  • SCS

    -0.0200

    12.95

    -0.15%

  • JRI

    -0.1000

    13.18

    -0.76%

  • RELX

    -0.2500

    46.04

    -0.54%

  • AZN

    -0.6000

    76.87

    -0.78%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    9.69

    +0.31%

  • BP

    0.2600

    33.14

    +0.78%

  • CMSD

    -0.0230

    24.79

    -0.09%

  • BCE

    -0.1800

    33.53

    -0.54%

Survivors wait for aid as Trump's lies help cloud Helene response
Survivors wait for aid as Trump's lies help cloud Helene response / Photo: Allison Joyce - AFP

Survivors wait for aid as Trump's lies help cloud Helene response

In the mountains of North Carolina, real frustrations over federal aid for victims of Hurricane Helene have been supercharged by a whirlwind of lies and misinformation -- fueled in part by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump.

Text size:

Ten days after Helene carved a path of destruction through the southeastern United States, many residents are still cut off -- from federal assistance, from electricity and running water, and, crucially, from accurate information.

Trump and others have poured false claims and conspiracy theories into that vacuum, targeting in particular the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) -- which, when a US state asks for help, puts the power of the federal government behind the disaster response.

The result? Anger, on top of grief, loss and devastation.

"FEMA should have been here, boots on the ground," Janet Musselwhite, a resident of Pensacola, North Carolina, which was hit hard by the storm, tells AFP.

The same thing happened after Hurricane Katrina in 2005, she said. "They waited and they waited and people died, and that's what has happened here."

Helene is now the deadliest storm to have struck the US mainland since Katrina, with a death toll of more than 230 people.

The United States has distributed more than $210 million in federal aid and dispatched nearly 7,000 emergency response personnel to assist with relief efforts across the US southeast, according to the White House.

But Trump and his Republican party have accused the administration of President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris -- who is also Trump's rival for the White House in November's election -- of misappropriating FEMA funds for migrants.

It's a false claim that has been repeatedly debunked, and that Harris rejected on Monday as "extraordinarily irresponsible."

But it's just one in a slew of falsehoods and rumors about the federal response that FEMA's chief has slammed as "dangerous."

The stakes could not be higher: even as FEMA and the Biden-Harris administration struggle to combat the misinformation and reach those in need, another storm, potentially catastrophic Hurricane Milton, is roaring towards Florida.

But the political stakes have also been thrown into stark relief: North Carolina and neighboring Georgia, which was also hit by Helene, are among a handful of "swing states" that will play a decisive role in whether Harris or Trump wins the White House in one month.

- Aid claims -

Helene survivors in North Carolina told AFP that the most impactful aid came from individual volunteers who helped deliver bottled water and food.

"Locals have been wonderful," Musselwhite said.

"Now we're hearing that there might not be very much FEMA money, because it was given to immigrants," she added, echoing Trump's falsehood.

"No money is being diverted from disaster response needs. None," the White House has said.

In the rural, largely conservative, mountainous areas of western North Carolina devastated by Helene, the false claims tap into the real challenges victims have faced with accessing federal aid.

Shelby Holzhauser, a 23-year-old preschool teacher in nearby Swannanoa, told AFP she has been encouraged to apply for disaster relief and unemployment insurance.

While she said the response from authorities has "been great," she has struggled to complete the application process because "it's all online" -- in an area where cell and internet service has been largely knocked out.

"From what I've heard, FEMA isn't really -- they're not letting anyone in to get supplies to everyone," Holzhauser said, repeating another misleading claim -- this one propagated by billionaire Elon Musk, a Trump ally and the owner of social media platform X, where much of the misinformation has swirled.

- 'It's been really hard' -

Veterinary technician Audria Pace, working at a makeshift vet clinic in Swannanoa, decried the impact misinformation has had on Helene's survivors.

"It's been really hard, because people have all these opinions, and if you have got time to share your hateful opinion, then you have time to help," she told AFP.

In one extreme example, "somebody has even gone as far to say that Biden manufactured this to kill Trump voters, that this is a red state, and this is something that people are left to die because they're Trump voters," Pace said.

Pace, who identifies as liberal, criticized the exploitation of the disaster for political purposes.

"They have no idea what's happening here," she said. "We are gathering our dead. We are tending our hearts. This is not helping."

A.Wyss--NZN