Zürcher Nachrichten - War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

EUR -
AED 3.995116
AFN 76.740719
ALL 99.211678
AMD 426.135515
ANG 1.959194
AOA 992.075198
ARS 1160.282071
AUD 1.721119
AWG 1.958043
AZN 1.848126
BAM 1.951077
BBD 2.194766
BDT 132.073027
BGN 1.950767
BHD 0.410039
BIF 3221.106824
BMD 1.087802
BND 1.450915
BOB 7.512024
BRL 6.23525
BSD 1.087009
BTN 94.49002
BWP 14.810559
BYN 3.557326
BYR 21320.917887
BZD 2.183555
CAD 1.565733
CDF 3128.518162
CHF 0.963526
CLF 0.026563
CLP 1019.281051
CNY 7.873347
CNH 7.875332
COP 4466.525615
CRC 543.060539
CUC 1.087802
CUP 28.826751
CVE 109.998744
CZK 25.020582
DJF 193.576778
DKK 7.460375
DOP 68.351411
DZD 145.326863
EGP 55.09489
ERN 16.317029
ETB 142.782614
FJD 2.493297
FKP 0.840358
GBP 0.841431
GEL 3.018663
GGP 0.840358
GHS 16.849679
GIP 0.840358
GMD 78.322203
GNF 9399.729127
GTQ 8.38033
GYD 227.435755
HKD 8.455348
HNL 27.801727
HRK 7.534228
HTG 142.558379
HUF 399.255762
IDR 17769.244576
ILS 3.978929
IMP 0.840358
INR 94.581278
IQD 1424.105264
IRR 45796.461018
ISK 146.10286
JEP 0.840358
JMD 170.237932
JOD 0.771223
JPY 161.498883
KES 140.815863
KGS 95.128529
KHR 4355.537332
KMF 491.522944
KPW 979.138653
KRW 1580.630411
KWD 0.335119
KYD 0.905932
KZT 544.81128
LAK 23548.433054
LBP 97401.821296
LKR 322.19567
LRD 217.410744
LSL 19.778507
LTL 3.211997
LVL 0.658001
LYD 5.232781
MAD 10.520538
MDL 19.344709
MGA 5068.823908
MKD 61.522384
MMK 2283.059928
MNT 3778.04543
MOP 8.702475
MRU 43.198833
MUR 49.114112
MVR 16.762624
MWK 1884.989295
MXN 21.603876
MYR 4.836908
MZN 69.515009
NAD 19.779051
NGN 1690.194096
NIO 40.00262
NOK 11.586285
NPR 151.182447
NZD 1.894418
OMR 0.41882
PAB 1.087089
PEN 3.987593
PGK 4.468185
PHP 62.25704
PKR 304.503937
PLN 4.178572
PYG 8631.42469
QAR 3.962046
RON 4.976912
RSD 117.158459
RUB 92.949301
RWF 1527.052842
SAR 4.079876
SBD 9.149664
SCR 15.63765
SDG 653.768905
SEK 11.016877
SGD 1.451895
SHP 0.854842
SLE 24.834564
SLL 22810.663812
SOS 621.321769
SRD 39.449683
STD 22515.30375
SVC 9.51154
SYP 14143.585018
SZL 19.785472
THB 36.565403
TJS 11.849145
TMT 3.818185
TND 3.35844
TOP 2.547741
TRY 39.895026
TTD 7.380795
TWD 35.849571
TZS 2893.553122
UAH 45.09325
UGX 3984.136489
USD 1.087802
UYU 46.328924
UZS 14080.916593
VES 69.572567
VND 27755.266321
VUV 134.059829
WST 3.010358
XAF 654.385067
XAG 0.032292
XAU 0.000365
XCD 2.939839
XDR 0.818567
XOF 654.373064
XPF 119.331742
YER 268.415361
ZAR 19.796032
ZMK 9791.518068
ZMW 31.117537
ZWL 350.271779
  • NGG

    0.6700

    62.99

    +1.06%

  • CMSC

    0.1090

    23.279

    +0.47%

  • BP

    0.8150

    33.185

    +2.46%

  • BTI

    -0.3150

    41.065

    -0.77%

  • BCC

    1.6200

    98

    +1.65%

  • SCS

    0.0850

    10.875

    +0.78%

  • BCE

    -0.2240

    23.445

    -0.96%

  • GSK

    0.2150

    39.445

    +0.55%

  • RIO

    1.1650

    62.365

    +1.87%

  • RBGPF

    -0.2300

    66.2

    -0.35%

  • RYCEF

    0.5200

    10.3

    +5.05%

  • VOD

    0.0380

    9.538

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.1350

    23.335

    +0.58%

  • JRI

    0.1035

    12.9

    +0.8%

  • RELX

    1.0260

    48.836

    +2.1%

  • AZN

    0.9550

    77.465

    +1.23%

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand
War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand / Photo: Lillian SUWANRUMPHA - AFP/File

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

More than a million people have fled Myanmar's brutal civil war to seek shelter and work in neighbouring Thailand, where experts say nationalists are using disinformation to fuel prejudice against them.

Text size:

Social media platforms have been flooded by false claims that Myanmar migrant workers were demanding a 700-baht ($21) minimum daily wage -- almost twice that paid to Thais.

One of them attracted millions of views, and a former Thai intelligence heavyweight was among those who shared the images.

Analysts say some Thai authorities deliberately reinforce the nationalistic ideologies that drive xenophobia in the country -- which was invaded by Burma in the 18th century.

That history has mutated into modern fears that workers from Myanmar are "stealing" jobs.

Linn, a 37-year-old factory worker in Bangkok, is still only making the official minimum wage of 400 baht a day after 17 years in Thailand.

"The clip claiming that Myanmar workers are demanding 700 baht is a fabrication", he said.

Nantiwat Samart, ex-deputy director of Thailand's National Intelligence Agency, was among those who amplified the claim.

Last month, he reuploaded three images from different events, falsely alleging they were of migrant workers demanding 700 baht a day.

"Thais have aided war refugees long enough," he posted on Facebook.

"They all should return from whence they came so that Thais have more jobs."

His post garnered almost 500 comments and was shared nearly 15,000 times, more than any other on the issue.

AFP debunked all of his images, but he did not respond to requests for comment.

- 'Hate speech' -

Thailand and Myanmar share many aspects of culture and religion, but their history also includes centuries of warfare.

Burmese forces invaded in the 16th century, followed by years of battles, including in 1767 when they burned the capital, killed civilians and soldiers and took thousands prisoner.

The story of Burmese aggression is embedded in Thai consciousness from school onwards.

Myanmar labour rights expert Hnin Wut Yee said authorities seek to exploit historical resentments.

"Referring to history or warning against these foreign invasions can trigger the nationalist mindset, or could sustain a sense of togetherness in defence of external enemies," she told AFP.

Migrants from Myanmar have long sought low-paid jobs in the richer neighbour, facing similar fears and prejudices as immigrants around the world.

Since Myanmar was plunged into civil war by a military coup in 2021, millions more have been displaced. Many fled to Thailand.

Thailand's Foreign Workers Administration Office says the number of registered migrant workers from Myanmar has soared from 1.5 million in 2020 to 2.3 million four years later.

The UN's International Organization for Migration (IOM) estimates another 1.8 million are working illegally, without them or their employers paying taxes or social security, and without legal protection.

IOM says Thailand has seen a "surge in anti-migrant sentiment and hate speech targeted towards Myanmar nationals", primarily fuelled by disinformation on social media.

- 'Coordinated campaign' -

Many migrants earn much less than the official minimum, taking low-paid, difficult and dangerous work that Thais are reluctant to do, but many still see them as a threat to their jobs or pay.

Growing migrant numbers are driving anti-migrant misinformation, according to Lalita Hanwong, a historian at Kasetsart University and security advisor to the Thai government.

"This is a coordinated campaign designed to curb the number of Burmese in Thailand," she said, by framing them as "national security threats".

AFP fact-checkers found that the videos of supposed minimum wage protests were old and were of other events.

The most widely circulated was actually shot by a Myanmar migrant demonstrating against high visa and work permit fees.

"I don't want someone to take advantage by manipulating my video," they told AFP, asking for anonymity out of concerns for their job and security.

"Also, I don't want negative impacts in my life because my video was used the wrong way."

The workers have endured prejudice for decades.

"Some Thais really like us due to our diligence and loyalty to our employers," said Cho, a 40-year-old garment worker in Bangkok.

"But at the same time, some may perceive us negatively, that we are taking their jobs."

F.Schneider--NZN