Zürcher Nachrichten - Gas giants' Myanmar exit unlikely to badly damage junta: analysts

EUR -
AED 3.818175
AFN 72.797719
ALL 98.449296
AMD 411.004828
ANG 1.872955
AOA 948.054394
ARS 1066.311715
AUD 1.668113
AWG 1.87116
AZN 1.768965
BAM 1.954396
BBD 2.098393
BDT 124.19081
BGN 1.955581
BHD 0.392145
BIF 3072.59335
BMD 1.039533
BND 1.410387
BOB 7.196831
BRL 6.437413
BSD 1.039254
BTN 88.509435
BWP 14.374677
BYN 3.400558
BYR 20374.855355
BZD 2.090099
CAD 1.497624
CDF 2983.460647
CHF 0.935829
CLF 0.037222
CLP 1027.163148
CNY 7.585372
CNH 7.588908
COP 4586.421522
CRC 527.721006
CUC 1.039533
CUP 27.547636
CVE 110.185868
CZK 25.132789
DJF 185.06709
DKK 7.460721
DOP 63.054716
DZD 140.566631
EGP 52.908195
ERN 15.593002
ETB 132.294989
FJD 2.411977
FKP 0.823292
GBP 0.829486
GEL 2.920682
GGP 0.823292
GHS 15.277028
GIP 0.823292
GMD 74.846661
GNF 8978.551858
GTQ 8.007249
GYD 217.423852
HKD 8.074363
HNL 26.398042
HRK 7.456476
HTG 135.892406
HUF 411.386519
IDR 16854.007582
ILS 3.816247
IMP 0.823292
INR 88.537577
IQD 1361.422265
IRR 43751.368531
ISK 145.098247
JEP 0.823292
JMD 162.233488
JOD 0.737345
JPY 163.308108
KES 134.359917
KGS 90.43918
KHR 4168.006655
KMF 484.552483
KPW 935.579512
KRW 1516.736442
KWD 0.320353
KYD 0.866078
KZT 542.14065
LAK 22741.667577
LBP 93065.16323
LKR 307.719005
LRD 189.144162
LSL 19.151746
LTL 3.069472
LVL 0.628803
LYD 5.103335
MAD 10.455991
MDL 19.13226
MGA 4899.481331
MKD 61.484688
MMK 3376.364052
MNT 3532.334482
MOP 8.317127
MRU 41.38328
MUR 48.930718
MVR 16.006255
MWK 1802.105779
MXN 20.946609
MYR 4.664402
MZN 66.430063
NAD 19.151746
NGN 1609.062836
NIO 38.242535
NOK 11.851383
NPR 141.615296
NZD 1.844195
OMR 0.400229
PAB 1.039254
PEN 3.876416
PGK 4.215972
PHP 60.790857
PKR 289.562045
PLN 4.272583
PYG 8113.173348
QAR 3.788779
RON 4.974478
RSD 116.96726
RUB 103.956844
RWF 1439.366288
SAR 3.902853
SBD 8.714986
SCR 14.844265
SDG 625.277692
SEK 11.524705
SGD 1.413157
SHP 0.823292
SLE 23.699822
SLL 21798.499544
SOS 593.973425
SRD 36.51156
STD 21516.243325
SVC 9.093469
SYP 2611.859198
SZL 19.14625
THB 35.502128
TJS 11.353846
TMT 3.648762
TND 3.309823
TOP 2.434695
TRY 36.647089
TTD 7.05893
TWD 33.975901
TZS 2515.671135
UAH 43.68063
UGX 3819.257117
USD 1.039533
UYU 46.496607
UZS 13408.370487
VES 53.614006
VND 26445.730624
VUV 123.415492
WST 2.87201
XAF 655.486248
XAG 0.035243
XAU 0.000398
XCD 2.809391
XDR 0.796728
XOF 655.486248
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.273179
ZAR 19.359023
ZMK 9357.102525
ZMW 28.761344
ZWL 334.729342
  • RIO

    -0.0800

    59.15

    -0.14%

  • BTI

    -0.0140

    36.206

    -0.04%

  • BCE

    0.1050

    22.945

    +0.46%

  • SCS

    -0.0250

    11.625

    -0.22%

  • CMSC

    -0.1522

    23.7499

    -0.64%

  • NGG

    -0.2730

    58.747

    -0.46%

  • AZN

    -0.3600

    66.27

    -0.54%

  • GSK

    -0.0150

    34.045

    -0.04%

  • JRI

    0.0310

    12.131

    +0.26%

  • BCC

    0.2100

    122.45

    +0.17%

  • RBGPF

    -0.7000

    59.8

    -1.17%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0200

    7.25

    -0.28%

  • BP

    0.1150

    28.865

    +0.4%

  • VOD

    0.0920

    8.462

    +1.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.2700

    23.28

    -1.16%

  • RELX

    0.1650

    45.755

    +0.36%

Gas giants' Myanmar exit unlikely to badly damage junta: analysts
Gas giants' Myanmar exit unlikely to badly damage junta: analysts

Gas giants' Myanmar exit unlikely to badly damage junta: analysts

The exit of energy titans TotalEnergies and Chevron from Myanmar's billion dollar gas industry has been hailed by rights groups, but analysts say it will not significantly weaken the generals and may even enrich the military in the short term.

Text size:

Both firms had faced pressure to cut financial links with the junta that toppled Aung San Suu Kyi's government last year and has since killed more than 1,400 people in a crackdown on dissent, according to a monitoring group.

The French firm and US oil major Chevron will withdraw from the Yadana gas field in the Andaman Sea, which provides electricity to the local Burmese and Thai population.

Myanmar's gas industry -- which Human Rights Watch says generates $1 billion a year -- has so far evaded swingeing sanctions imposed by the United States and EU on lucrative military-owned timber and jade enterprises.

Friday's "announcement is certainly significant," Manny Maung, Myanmar researcher at Human Rights Watch told AFP.

"But there is a lot more pressure needed to defeat this junta for good.

"Governments no longer have an excuse to delay imposing targeted sanctions on oil and gas entities... to prevent any other unscrupulous entities from entering the market."

TotalEnergies and Chevron's departure will deprive the junta of hundreds of millions of dollars a year in foreign revenue as the economy it presides over tanks from months of unrest and a mass walkout.

TotalEnergies alone paid around $176 million to Myanmar authorities in 2020 in the form of taxes and "production rights", according to the company's own financial statements.

Naw Susanna Hla Hla Soe, a minister in a shadow government dominated by lawmakers from Suu Kyi's party which is working to topple the military said the news sent a "very strong message" to the junta.

"Other companies must follow Total's example to put even more pressure on the generals," she added.

- 'No confidence' -

If the French and American titans were willing -- belatedly -- to bow to rights groups and activist pressure, there are others with fewer qualms about making money in junta-run Myanmar.

"It will be harder to force the hand of Asian investors because their human rights commitments and the stakeholder pressures on them are lower," Dr Htwe Htwe Thein at Curtin University in Australia, told AFP.

Others say it is possible the junta will profit short-term from any change in ownership.

The withdrawal of TotalEnergies is "a big vote of no confidence in the regime", International Crisis Group's Myanmar senior advisor Richard Horsey told AFP.

But the junta would likely be able to "sell the departing operators' stakes", he added -- which would inject much needed hard currency into the state coffers.

The military would also be able to "attract and negotiate favourable terms and signature payments from operators in jurisdictions beyond the scope of Western sanctions".

TotalEnergies will not exit immediately -- it said in a statement it will continue to operate the site for the next six months at the latest until its contractual period ends.

"As things stand... Means likely cash windfall for the regime unless ways are found to prevent that, which must be priority," Horsey said on Twitter.

And the generals' economic portfolio stretches far beyond gas, and includes interests in mines, banks, agriculture and tourism, providing the military with a colossal -- and closely guarded -- fortune.

The jade industry alone -- dominated by military-owned business -- provides the military with billions of dollars a year in off-the-books revenue, analysts say.

There also remains the question of how easy TotalEnergies and Chevron will find it to exit junta-ruled Myanmar, said Htwe Htwe Thein, citing Norway's Telenor, which announced it was withdrawing in July, but whose exit has been held up by the military.

"Total may suffer the same fate," she said.

H.Roth--NZN