Zürcher Nachrichten - C.Africa's leap into bitcoin leaves its people bemused

EUR -
AED 3.766641
AFN 73.23806
ALL 98.213989
AMD 412.332779
ANG 1.856297
AOA 935.240708
ARS 1062.018763
AUD 1.66908
AWG 1.848433
AZN 1.747392
BAM 1.955481
BBD 2.079661
BDT 125.649516
BGN 1.955987
BHD 0.386137
BIF 3046.903275
BMD 1.025483
BND 1.40867
BOB 7.11684
BRL 6.280229
BSD 1.030032
BTN 88.642549
BWP 14.496637
BYN 3.37075
BYR 20099.463259
BZD 2.068963
CAD 1.479356
CDF 2943.136063
CHF 0.93984
CLF 0.037515
CLP 1035.163783
CNY 7.519562
CNH 7.551092
COP 4459.872923
CRC 519.91524
CUC 1.025483
CUP 27.175295
CVE 110.247027
CZK 25.104029
DJF 183.420098
DKK 7.46716
DOP 63.229692
DZD 139.334285
EGP 51.791557
ERN 15.382242
ETB 129.247629
FJD 2.398301
FKP 0.812164
GBP 0.840274
GEL 2.89703
GGP 0.812164
GHS 15.192523
GIP 0.812164
GMD 73.325971
GNF 8906.547999
GTQ 7.948704
GYD 215.494869
HKD 7.985999
HNL 26.19473
HRK 7.355692
HTG 134.558063
HUF 413.751951
IDR 16732.956986
ILS 3.785027
IMP 0.812164
INR 88.392009
IQD 1349.280032
IRR 43160.012072
ISK 144.839589
JEP 0.812164
JMD 161.513669
JOD 0.727482
JPY 161.772006
KES 133.328264
KGS 89.217365
KHR 4163.321269
KMF 490.232455
KPW 922.933964
KRW 1511.689901
KWD 0.316366
KYD 0.85836
KZT 543.59138
LAK 22474.336092
LBP 92236.063097
LKR 303.410536
LRD 192.6086
LSL 19.575809
LTL 3.027985
LVL 0.620305
LYD 5.09117
MAD 10.352112
MDL 19.250862
MGA 4877.204887
MKD 61.519971
MMK 3330.728196
MNT 3484.590487
MOP 8.259753
MRU 41.107298
MUR 48.023749
MVR 15.796269
MWK 1786.008834
MXN 21.244214
MYR 4.611088
MZN 65.532176
NAD 19.575809
NGN 1591.006216
NIO 37.903821
NOK 11.768944
NPR 141.827878
NZD 1.845655
OMR 0.394366
PAB 1.030032
PEN 3.875868
PGK 4.129327
PHP 60.512755
PKR 286.853535
PLN 4.269649
PYG 8087.681495
QAR 3.755088
RON 4.980877
RSD 117.065915
RUB 104.230108
RWF 1432.766421
SAR 3.849289
SBD 8.65448
SCR 14.727599
SDG 616.315522
SEK 11.50462
SGD 1.405223
SHP 0.812164
SLE 23.330115
SLL 21503.865086
SOS 588.604042
SRD 35.999613
STD 21225.423919
SVC 9.012531
SYP 2576.556598
SZL 19.571809
THB 35.613006
TJS 11.237268
TMT 3.58919
TND 3.306261
TOP 2.401787
TRY 36.336395
TTD 6.99186
TWD 33.955073
TZS 2592.477358
UAH 43.558099
UGX 3808.379134
USD 1.025483
UYU 44.972668
UZS 13345.82428
VES 55.18254
VND 26016.499127
VUV 121.747374
WST 2.833191
XAF 655.850079
XAG 0.033731
XAU 0.000381
XCD 2.771419
XDR 0.793171
XOF 655.850079
XPF 119.331742
YER 255.601965
ZAR 19.600823
ZMK 9230.579631
ZMW 28.453361
ZWL 330.205049
  • NGG

    -1.8500

    56.13

    -3.3%

  • RELX

    -0.4000

    46.37

    -0.86%

  • RBGPF

    60.4900

    60.49

    +100%

  • RIO

    0.2100

    58.84

    +0.36%

  • CMSC

    -0.1800

    22.92

    -0.79%

  • SCS

    -0.3300

    10.97

    -3.01%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    7.07

    -0.42%

  • AZN

    0.4300

    67.01

    +0.64%

  • GSK

    -0.6600

    33.09

    -1.99%

  • CMSD

    -0.1500

    23.25

    -0.65%

  • BCC

    -1.5200

    115.88

    -1.31%

  • BTI

    -0.8400

    35.9

    -2.34%

  • JRI

    -0.1400

    12.08

    -1.16%

  • BCE

    -0.6700

    22.96

    -2.92%

  • VOD

    -0.1600

    8.05

    -1.99%

  • BP

    0.1700

    31.29

    +0.54%

C.Africa's leap into bitcoin leaves its people bemused
C.Africa's leap into bitcoin leaves its people bemused / Photo: FLORENT VERGNES - AFP

C.Africa's leap into bitcoin leaves its people bemused

In the Central African Republic (CAR), nine out of 10 people do not have internet, and only one in seven has electricity -- that is, when there are no power cuts.

Text size:

Yet the CAR has just followed El Salvador in adopting bitcoin as legal tender, a currency that requires access to the net to be bought, sold or used.

Foreign experts and CAR citizens themselves are struggling to understand why the world's second least developed economy has announced this leap into monetary hyperspace.

Among people queueing at one of the rare automatic teller machines (ATMs) in the capital Bangui, the word "bitcoin" stirred befuddlement.

"What is it?" asked Sylvain, a man in his 30s, waiting for his turn at the cash machine, which was operating thanks to a generator.

"I don't know what cryptocurrencies are -- I don't even have internet," said Joelle, a vegetable hawker nearby.

On April 28, President Faustin Archange Touadera announced that lawmakers had unanimously approved a bill that legalised the use of bitcoin alongside the CFA franc.

All transactions using the cryptocurrency, including payment of taxes, are being authorised.

Government spokesman Serge Ghislain Djorie told AFP: "We are going to launch an awareness campaign and shortly introduce fibre optic cable -- a low internet connection is enough to buy cryptocurrency."

But even among CAR's business community, which in theory is best placed to use bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies regulated by the new law, scepticism runs deep.

"I'm not interested in having bitcoin here -- we have no infrastructure and no knowledge for getting involved in this adventure and there's no cybercrime unit to ensure security," said an entrepreneur, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.

"There are other priorities, like security, energy, access to water, the internet, building roads..."

- Sickly economy -

Technical hurdles are just one of the questions raised by the bitcoin move.

Foreign analysts have been pondering why this deeply troubled economy should adopt a novel and volatile currency rather than a time-honoured stable unit such as the US dollar.

Just this week, Economy Minister Herve Ndoba said a shortfall in government income was so severe that without foreign help, spending cuts of up to 60 percent loomed for some ministries.

"CAR has many problems. Adding another currency like bitcoin as legal tender will unlikely meaningfully address those," said Ousmene Jacques Mandeng, a visiting fellow at the London School of Economics (LSE).

Bitcoin's "excess volatility... translates to fluctuations in household savings, consumption and wealth," warned Ganesh Viswanath-Nastraj, an assistant professor of finance at Warwick Business School in England.

Locked in a nine-year-old civil conflict, the CAR is heavily dependent on mineral extraction, much of which is informal, for its economy.

In a report in December 2020, a US watchdog called The Sentry said the CAR had become "a breeding ground for transnational criminal networks."

"Money laundering and the trafficking of natural resources, drugs, weapons, and diplomatic passports are rampant," it said.

The CFA franc that until now was the CAR's sole legal tender is a regional currency backed by France and pegged to the euro.

Other members of the currency are Cameroon, Chad, the Republic of Congo, Gabon and Equatorial Guinea.

Didier Loukakou, regulatory chief at the Central African Financial Market Surveillance Commission, said the six had been discussing plans to regulate crypto-currencies.

But, he said, "we were not warned by Bangui about its decision."

- Russian factor? -

Some experts see a possible explanation for Touadera's announcement in his entwinement with Russia, perceived as desperate for currency after Western countries imposed sanctions over its invasion of Ukraine.

In 2020, Russia sent paramilitaries to shore up Touadera as armed groups advanced on the capital.

France and rights campaigners describe these operatives as mercenaries from the Wagner group, which reputedly receives mineral wealth in exchange for their services.

"The context, given systemic corruption and a Russian partner facing international sanctions, does encourage suspicion," said Thierry Vircoulon, a specialist on Central Africa at the French Institute of International Relations (IFRI) think tank.

"Russia's search for ways to get around international sanctions is an invitation to be cautious."

But some voices, including the head of the International Monetary Fund, Kristalina Georgieva, have voiced doubts that digital currencies can be an effective tool for bypassing sanctions.

W.Vogt--NZN