Zürcher Nachrichten - Forbidden love: Taiwan's gay couples seek foreign marriage equality

EUR -
AED 4.057174
AFN 80.158161
ALL 99.191302
AMD 433.739496
ANG 1.977442
AOA 1012.348633
ARS 1188.956163
AUD 1.795027
AWG 1.988258
AZN 1.876518
BAM 1.966585
BBD 2.239903
BDT 134.786772
BGN 1.959544
BHD 0.416367
BIF 3297.796582
BMD 1.104588
BND 1.494154
BOB 7.666043
BRL 6.518395
BSD 1.109334
BTN 96.301429
BWP 15.73695
BYN 3.630545
BYR 21649.922955
BZD 2.228441
CAD 1.554785
CDF 3175.690544
CHF 0.933531
CLF 0.028253
CLP 1084.186556
CNY 8.118776
CNH 8.122907
COP 4752.213318
CRC 570.613928
CUC 1.104588
CUP 29.27158
CVE 110.862971
CZK 25.122774
DJF 197.544454
DKK 7.465423
DOP 69.046799
DZD 147.143289
EGP 56.645811
ERN 16.568819
ETB 146.735429
FJD 2.552868
FKP 0.865302
GBP 0.857983
GEL 3.043143
GGP 0.865302
GHS 17.196388
GIP 0.865302
GMD 78.978827
GNF 9603.494687
GTQ 8.55615
GYD 232.103982
HKD 8.574038
HNL 28.741587
HRK 7.539251
HTG 145.168119
HUF 406.033282
IDR 18655.882207
ILS 4.165611
IMP 0.865302
INR 95.300527
IQD 1453.35751
IRR 46503.150391
ISK 145.099078
JEP 0.865302
JMD 175.405627
JOD 0.783039
JPY 161.563662
KES 143.099572
KGS 96.531155
KHR 4443.429499
KMF 496.511574
KPW 994.135399
KRW 1618.439958
KWD 0.339793
KYD 0.924571
KZT 575.918517
LAK 24031.579142
LBP 98873.505482
LKR 333.948455
LRD 221.866701
LSL 21.878591
LTL 3.261561
LVL 0.668155
LYD 6.149447
MAD 10.549102
MDL 19.691818
MGA 5142.084421
MKD 61.544912
MMK 2319.09138
MNT 3881.786455
MOP 8.866949
MRU 43.953463
MUR 49.815061
MVR 17.021812
MWK 1923.706671
MXN 22.552042
MYR 4.938064
MZN 70.584631
NAD 21.87879
NGN 1740.830725
NIO 40.822776
NOK 12.016503
NPR 154.090501
NZD 1.946256
OMR 0.425274
PAB 1.109384
PEN 4.154711
PGK 4.582046
PHP 63.389013
PKR 311.319518
PLN 4.262908
PYG 8877.283967
QAR 4.044314
RON 4.978045
RSD 117.158146
RUB 94.265908
RWF 1571.080741
SAR 4.145918
SBD 9.193766
SCR 15.983396
SDG 663.30415
SEK 11.028062
SGD 1.480164
SHP 0.868033
SLE 25.14015
SLL 23162.657288
SOS 633.9625
SRD 40.806236
STD 22862.739497
SVC 9.707149
SYP 14361.775366
SZL 21.895487
THB 37.822746
TJS 12.052609
TMT 3.877104
TND 3.419645
TOP 2.587052
TRY 41.918667
TTD 7.524128
TWD 36.331552
TZS 2947.863422
UAH 45.810502
UGX 4097.490468
USD 1.104588
UYU 47.556509
UZS 14378.858159
VES 80.928661
VND 28500.577147
VUV 139.194128
WST 3.184242
XAF 659.559302
XAG 0.035748
XAU 0.000356
XCD 2.985204
XDR 0.82028
XOF 659.544293
XPF 119.331742
YER 270.950929
ZAR 21.530903
ZMK 9942.615003
ZMW 31.162778
ZWL 355.676855
  • RBGPF

    60.2700

    60.27

    +100%

  • BCC

    8.5100

    98.44

    +8.64%

  • SCS

    0.8700

    10.61

    +8.2%

  • CMSC

    0.3900

    22.6

    +1.73%

  • BTI

    0.6600

    40.21

    +1.64%

  • CMSD

    0.3700

    22.75

    +1.63%

  • RIO

    3.2900

    55.61

    +5.92%

  • GSK

    0.3500

    34.48

    +1.02%

  • AZN

    1.8600

    66.76

    +2.79%

  • NGG

    2.4700

    65.21

    +3.79%

  • RELX

    3.2300

    48.54

    +6.65%

  • JRI

    0.5200

    11.99

    +4.34%

  • BCE

    0.1300

    21

    +0.62%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    9.3

    +1.08%

  • BP

    1.7900

    27.9

    +6.42%

  • VOD

    0.3900

    8.58

    +4.55%

Forbidden love: Taiwan's gay couples seek foreign marriage equality
Forbidden love: Taiwan's gay couples seek foreign marriage equality / Photo: Sam YEH - AFP/File

Forbidden love: Taiwan's gay couples seek foreign marriage equality

Taiwan's LGBTQ community celebrated the third year of gay marriage being legal this week, but for Vincent Chuang it was a bittersweet reminder that he still cannot wed because he fell in love with a foreigner.

Text size:

Socially progressive Taiwan is at the vanguard of Asia's gay rights movement, and became the first in the region to legalise same-sex unions on May 17, 2019.

But the law still contains restrictions that heterosexual couples do not face, including limits on which foreigners same-sex couples can wed.

Under the current rules, Taiwanese nationals can only marry those from the roughly 30 countries and territories where same-sex marriage is also legal.

Activists say that discriminates against most transnational couples and keeps them apart, especially during the pandemic, which has seen partners unable to cross borders and enter Taiwan as dependants or spouses.

For Chuang, a 36-year-old teacher, the enforced split from his Filipino partner Andrew Espera has been painful.

"We are just two persons who love each other and who want to be with each other. We are not asking for anything extravagant, only this small right," he told AFP.

Chuang met Espera, a cook, six years ago during a trip to the Philippines.

"He was a chef at the bed and breakfast place I was staying. It was love at first sight," he recalled.

The pandemic forced the couple into a video call relationship, with Espera teaching his partner Tagalog and cooking as they tried various ways to be reunited.

They almost gave up until Espera eventually secured a student visa and they were finally reunited this week. But both feel they have been denied a basic right given to heterosexuals.

"We are hoping and praying for this, (that) Taiwan can accept us, accept our relationship and allow us to be legalised partners even though my country is yet to legalise same-sex marriage," Espera, 31, told AFP.

- 'Missing piece' -

The Taiwan Alliance to Promote Civil Partnership Rights says some 470 transnational same-sex couples currently wish to get married but are unable.

The advocacy group has launched multiple legal battles to push for full marital recognition involving foreigners.

So far they have won three cases. But the rulings only apply to the couples in question, meaning anyone who wants to follow in their footsteps would need to launch the same time-consuming legal battle.

Alliance secretary general Chien Chih-chieh said Taiwan's government often "basks in the fame of being Asia's first" to legalise gay marriage.

"But there is still an obvious missing piece that needs to be mended."

Government employee Lee Wei-cheng last saw his partner, a 33-year-old from Myanmar, when they joined a huge 2019 Pride march in Taiwan that drew a record crowd of 200,000 to celebrate gay marriage legalisation.

Since then, they have been kept separated by both the pandemic and last year's coup in Myanmar.

Every day Lee, 31, worries for the safety of his partner, who is ethnic Karen, amid ongoing fighting between a Karen armed group and junta troops.

"We hope to live together in Taiwan and we thought getting married would be the easiest way, but we are still unable to do it," he told AFP.

"We've been separated for three years and we feel so helpless. As Taiwanese, I should have the right to marry whom I want to marry, but I've been deprived of that right -- the freedom of marriage".

Malaysian Tan Bee Guat has been living in Taipei on a student visa for six years in order to be with her partner Lai Kai-li, but the couple laments that their future is forever in limbo without a legal marriage.

"I was happy and feeling hopeful when Taiwan legalised gay marriage because it's unthinkable in Malaysia, not even after 50 years," Tan said in an interview in their rented apartment.

The couple is struggling financially, having to mostly rely on 39-year-old Lai's income as an independent publisher, because Tan as a foreign student is only allowed to work a maximum of 20 hours a week.

"I am losing faith and I am tired. I am already in my 40s but I don't have a career, I don't have money," Tan said.

But the campaign to secure full equal rights must continue, they argued.

"We are treated differently because of our sexual orientation," said Lai. "This is discrimination".

R.Bernasconi--NZN