Zürcher Nachrichten - Indonesia's new coal phase-out goal sets 'daunting task'

EUR -
AED 3.82096
AFN 72.95795
ALL 98.661714
AMD 411.511459
ANG 1.877014
AOA 948.73034
ARS 1067.056125
AUD 1.666545
AWG 1.872494
AZN 1.771352
BAM 1.958698
BBD 2.102991
BDT 124.462962
BGN 1.955092
BHD 0.392322
BIF 3079.326649
BMD 1.040274
BND 1.413464
BOB 7.212221
BRL 6.445753
BSD 1.041506
BTN 88.703395
BWP 14.405692
BYN 3.408043
BYR 20389.374639
BZD 2.094679
CAD 1.495654
CDF 2985.587061
CHF 0.934801
CLF 0.037342
CLP 1030.37048
CNY 7.591877
CNH 7.603151
COP 4589.689842
CRC 528.882548
CUC 1.040274
CUP 27.567267
CVE 110.42733
CZK 25.140322
DJF 184.877592
DKK 7.460384
DOP 63.191373
DZD 140.258299
EGP 53.137492
ERN 15.604113
ETB 132.577882
FJD 2.412552
FKP 0.823878
GBP 0.830144
GEL 2.923419
GGP 0.823878
GHS 15.309696
GIP 0.823878
GMD 74.899648
GNF 8998.227508
GTQ 8.024797
GYD 217.888779
HKD 8.082811
HNL 26.456145
HRK 7.461789
HTG 136.191512
HUF 412.656077
IDR 16890.51634
ILS 3.816574
IMP 0.823878
INR 88.526555
IQD 1364.405694
IRR 43782.54872
ISK 145.107732
JEP 0.823878
JMD 162.589008
JOD 0.737659
JPY 163.530588
KES 134.622118
KGS 90.504093
KHR 4176.999707
KMF 484.897784
KPW 936.246213
KRW 1511.221987
KWD 0.320611
KYD 0.867947
KZT 543.333931
LAK 22790.297087
LBP 93264.16857
LKR 308.396311
LRD 189.555004
LSL 19.1939
LTL 3.071659
LVL 0.629252
LYD 5.114568
MAD 10.479005
MDL 19.17354
MGA 4910.170813
MKD 61.498942
MMK 3378.770076
MNT 3534.851652
MOP 8.334912
MRU 41.473967
MUR 48.736726
MVR 16.021999
MWK 1806.037537
MXN 21.00156
MYR 4.671866
MZN 66.477402
NAD 19.1939
NGN 1611.395012
NIO 38.326709
NOK 11.821411
NPR 141.920851
NZD 1.842971
OMR 0.400511
PAB 1.041476
PEN 3.884948
PGK 4.225252
PHP 60.918978
PKR 290.199386
PLN 4.266137
PYG 8131.030881
QAR 3.797082
RON 4.975736
RSD 116.998606
RUB 105.300239
RWF 1442.444148
SAR 3.907617
SBD 8.721196
SCR 14.50713
SDG 625.721598
SEK 11.494354
SGD 1.412021
SHP 0.823878
SLE 23.72519
SLL 21814.033329
SOS 595.275062
SRD 36.537536
STD 21531.575972
SVC 9.113485
SYP 2613.72043
SZL 19.188392
THB 35.694956
TJS 11.378124
TMT 3.651362
TND 3.317108
TOP 2.436424
TRY 36.681843
TTD 7.074468
TWD 33.999074
TZS 2504.46173
UAH 43.776352
UGX 3827.62666
USD 1.040274
UYU 46.598949
UZS 13437.753668
VES 53.649239
VND 26474.978804
VUV 123.503438
WST 2.874057
XAF 656.900551
XAG 0.035013
XAU 0.000398
XCD 2.811393
XDR 0.798474
XOF 656.922685
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.458683
ZAR 19.29381
ZMK 9363.723842
ZMW 28.822846
ZWL 334.967873
  • RIO

    0.5900

    59.23

    +1%

  • NGG

    0.5200

    59.02

    +0.88%

  • CMSC

    0.0420

    23.902

    +0.18%

  • GSK

    0.4600

    34.06

    +1.35%

  • BTI

    -0.0200

    36.22

    -0.06%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    60.5

    0%

  • RELX

    0.1200

    45.59

    +0.26%

  • VOD

    -0.0200

    8.37

    -0.24%

  • SCS

    -0.0900

    11.65

    -0.77%

  • BCC

    -0.5100

    122.24

    -0.42%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0200

    7.25

    -0.28%

  • AZN

    1.2800

    66.63

    +1.92%

  • BP

    0.1500

    28.75

    +0.52%

  • CMSD

    -0.0100

    23.55

    -0.04%

  • JRI

    0.0400

    12.1

    +0.33%

  • BCE

    -0.3200

    22.84

    -1.4%

Indonesia's new coal phase-out goal sets 'daunting task'
Indonesia's new coal phase-out goal sets 'daunting task' / Photo: Ronald SIAGIAN - AFP/File

Indonesia's new coal phase-out goal sets 'daunting task'

Meeting Indonesia's pledge to phase out coal power in just 15 years and reach net-zero emissions by mid-century is a "daunting task" that will require immediate and ambitious action, experts warn.

Text size:

New President Prabowo Subianto offered a surprise commitment at last month's G20 summit to close hundreds of coal and fossil-fuel power plants by 2040, a bold pledge from one of the world's top coal producers and consumers.

"It will be difficult to achieve. We need a total change to do it," said Fahmy Radhi, a lecturer and energy economist at Gadjahmada University.

Indonesia currently has 253 operational coal-fired power plants, according to the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, including Southeast Asia's biggest at the Suralaya complex on Java island.

Dozens more are under construction, including so-called captive coal plants that supply energy to industry rather than the grid.

Shutting down this network to achieve Prabowo's target of meeting net-zero emissions a decade earlier than previously planned could cost tens of billions of dollars, according to estimates by researchers.

And while Indonesia secured a $20 billion Just Energy Transition Partnership with developed nations in 2022, which was supposed to speed its clean energy transition, little of that money has been seen so far.

Jakarta's goal before Prabowo's announcement was to close 13 coal-fired plants by 2030, indicating the ambition in his new timeline.

The government says it wants to build over 75 gigawatts of renewable energy capacity by 2040 but so far has laid out little detail on how it hopes to achieve its new aims.

Prabowo's brother Hashim Djojohadikusumo, a businessman with interests in mining and renewable energy who is now special envoy for energy and the environment, said Jakarta wants to build two nuclear power plants.

But construction is far off, with Jakarta yet to even propose locations for them.

"The commitment is there, but I currently don't see any implementation or realisation," said Fahmy.

- Gear shift -

The archipelago's coal addiction has proven hard to break before.

Prabowo's predecessor Joko Widodo announced a moratorium on new coal power plant construction in 2022.

However, projects agreed before the ban continued and coal still accounts for two-thirds of power generation, according to the International Energy Agency.

That reflects the fact that coal is a cheap, reliable resource for rapidly expanding economies like Indonesia, where energy demand is steadily growing.

Indonesia's coal plants are also mostly young, making retiring them early an expensive prospect.

The Institute for Essential Services Reform (IESR), a Jakarta-based energy think tank, estimated Indonesia would need $27 billion by 2040 to shut down coal power plants that generate a total capacity of 45 gigawatts.

And state electricity company PLN, which says shutting a single plant could run close to $2 billion, insists it will not shoulder the cost.

"Shutting down a coal power plant must be cost-neutral. If there are additional costs, they're not the responsibility of the government or PLN," its director Darmawan Prasodjo told parliament last week.

Campaigners argue a gear shift is needed.

"There are still many policies that don't aim for the real energy transition," Adila Isfandiary, a climate and energy campaigner at Greenpeace Indonesia, told AFP.

"Our investment climate is not that good, (investors) still don't see renewable energy as a bankable project for them, especially because coal is still very cheap," she said.

- 'Actually doable' -

Experts say there is a pathway to achieving its targets if the government is serious.

It will need to retire three gigawatts of coal capacity annually over the next 15 years while swiftly ramping up renewable energy, particularly solar, according to energy think tank Ember.

Indonesia launched the region's largest floating solar plant last year with a capacity of 192 megawatts and it also has untapped biomass and geothermal energy capacity.

Most of all, the government needs to match its bold initiative with a bold roadmap, said IESR executive director Fabby Tumiwa.

"This whole thing is a daunting task and a very expensive one at that," he told AFP.

"We need to treat this as a mission and to achieve it we need changes, improvement, and reformation.

The government must ensure no new coal construction after next year and refuse extensions to the plants set for retirement.

It can also streamline regulations and provide incentives for renewable energy, he said.

"Now it might feel like a mission to Mars," Fabby said.

"But if we approach it aggressively, it's actually doable."

F.Schneider--NZN