Zürcher Nachrichten - Trans-themed film dazzles Cannes in Pakistan debut

EUR -
AED 4.172469
AFN 81.226466
ALL 100.310777
AMD 444.244667
ANG 2.03356
AOA 1042.821867
ARS 1220.13733
AUD 1.807145
AWG 2.044748
AZN 1.935661
BAM 1.960237
BBD 2.294213
BDT 138.054564
BGN 1.961833
BHD 0.42777
BIF 3323.851373
BMD 1.135971
BND 1.500396
BOB 7.851771
BRL 6.659749
BSD 1.136282
BTN 97.823546
BWP 15.847869
BYN 3.718549
BYR 22265.033118
BZD 2.282366
CAD 1.575649
CDF 3265.353315
CHF 0.926352
CLF 0.02877
CLP 1104.02802
CNY 8.283619
CNH 8.27647
COP 4864.114557
CRC 583.02471
CUC 1.135971
CUP 30.103234
CVE 111.723203
CZK 25.124845
DJF 201.885227
DKK 7.469696
DOP 70.093827
DZD 149.546094
EGP 58.259952
ERN 17.039566
ETB 147.907835
FJD 2.589451
FKP 0.877892
GBP 0.868347
GEL 3.135724
GGP 0.877892
GHS 17.676153
GIP 0.877892
GMD 81.226307
GNF 9831.830079
GTQ 8.763913
GYD 237.718034
HKD 8.810308
HNL 29.302419
HRK 7.534333
HTG 148.666666
HUF 409.938323
IDR 19081.076584
ILS 4.222235
IMP 0.877892
INR 97.656196
IQD 1488.122111
IRR 47824.382762
ISK 145.295033
JEP 0.877892
JMD 180.107643
JOD 0.805522
JPY 163.023646
KES 147.112573
KGS 99.341107
KHR 4563.196216
KMF 499.263598
KPW 1022.440932
KRW 1614.46525
KWD 0.348539
KYD 0.946943
KZT 587.183822
LAK 24605.133934
LBP 101726.210383
LKR 338.924114
LRD 227.024253
LSL 22.095071
LTL 3.354228
LVL 0.687138
LYD 6.316432
MAD 10.683852
MDL 20.140585
MGA 5287.945759
MKD 61.62647
MMK 2385.165785
MNT 3990.8206
MOP 9.077145
MRU 45.15528
MUR 50.554963
MVR 17.498202
MWK 1972.046182
MXN 23.08279
MYR 5.023837
MZN 72.60034
NAD 22.077642
NGN 1814.225757
NIO 41.758725
NOK 12.117749
NPR 156.517874
NZD 1.949496
OMR 0.43697
PAB 1.136272
PEN 4.234337
PGK 4.574599
PHP 64.754939
PKR 318.810708
PLN 4.289102
PYG 9090.574971
QAR 4.135621
RON 4.979761
RSD 117.292465
RUB 94.489935
RWF 1607.399075
SAR 4.264475
SBD 9.490317
SCR 16.273869
SDG 682.154808
SEK 11.102759
SGD 1.498918
SHP 0.892695
SLE 25.877842
SLL 23820.746739
SOS 649.211631
SRD 42.083228
STD 23512.307787
SVC 9.942503
SYP 14770.008163
SZL 22.095057
THB 38.010012
TJS 12.345442
TMT 3.975899
TND 3.413029
TOP 2.660562
TRY 43.085154
TTD 7.726556
TWD 36.779567
TZS 3044.974597
UAH 47.038564
UGX 4175.524104
USD 1.135971
UYU 49.292433
UZS 14739.22511
VES 87.603875
VND 29259.775028
VUV 142.891608
WST 3.235249
XAF 657.445015
XAG 0.035233
XAU 0.000351
XCD 3.070019
XDR 0.819926
XOF 676.474861
XPF 119.331742
YER 278.657784
ZAR 21.729281
ZMK 10225.106937
ZMW 32.070586
ZWL 365.782223
  • RBGPF

    62.0100

    62.01

    +100%

  • BCC

    0.9800

    95.66

    +1.02%

  • VOD

    0.2800

    8.73

    +3.21%

  • NGG

    2.4700

    68.06

    +3.63%

  • RELX

    0.1000

    49.12

    +0.2%

  • GSK

    1.0400

    34.64

    +3%

  • SCS

    -0.0300

    10.18

    -0.29%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    9.12

    -0.11%

  • CMSD

    -0.3000

    21.9

    -1.37%

  • CMSC

    -0.3500

    21.8

    -1.61%

  • RIO

    1.9900

    56.86

    +3.5%

  • JRI

    0.1450

    11.91

    +1.22%

  • BCE

    0.3800

    21.36

    +1.78%

  • BTI

    1.0200

    41.57

    +2.45%

  • AZN

    1.4200

    66.29

    +2.14%

  • BP

    0.3600

    26.59

    +1.35%

Trans-themed film dazzles Cannes in Pakistan debut
Trans-themed film dazzles Cannes in Pakistan debut / Photo: Julie SEBADELHA - AFP

Trans-themed film dazzles Cannes in Pakistan debut

The first-ever Pakistani entry in a Cannes Film Festival competition has left audiences slack-jawed and admiring of its daring portrait of a transgender dancer in the Muslim country.

Text size:

"Joyland" by director Saim Sadiq, a tale of sexual revolution, tells the story of the youngest son in a patriarchal family who is expected to produce a baby boy with his wife but joins an erotic dance theatre and falls for the troupe's director, a trans woman.

The Cannes opening night's audience gave "Joyland" a standing ovation, Variety lauding the movie as "so fresh, we're continuously surprised", while Deadline called it "thoughtful, well performed and engrossing".

Part of the surprise stemmed from the discovery by many at Cannes that Pakistan became one the first nations to give legal protection against discrimination to transgender people.

In 2009, Pakistan legally recognised a third sex, and in 2018, the first transgender passport was issued.

"Pakistan is very schizophrenic, almost bipolar," director Saim Sadiq told AFP in an interview.

"You get, of course, prejudice and some violence against a particular community on the one hand, but you also get this very progressive law which basically allows everyone to identify their own gender, and also identifies a third gender," he said.

"Is it implemented entirely? Of course not. But it's only been four years since the legislative change started happening."

- 'Associated with poetry' -

Before the British established their Indian Empire in the 19th century, trans people were not marginalised, said Sadiq.

"They were associated with art and poetry, they were the ones asked to teach manners to royals, to educate princes and princesses -- that was their space in society," he said.

Today, trans people in Pakistan "don't live as freely as they would perhaps in France", he added.

"But nor is it like it might be in the imagination of somebody who thinks: 'Muslim world'. At some level, they are freer than what you might anticipate," he added.

"Joyland" makes clear that the challenges for the trans community are broadly similar to those faced by cisgender women in Pakistan, where heterosexual men get to explore their desires, unlike everybody else.

"It's pretty terrible for anybody who is not a straight man," said Sadiq.

But he quickly added: "It's the same in the rest of the world, there's no country in the world where a straight man is not at the top of the pile."

There is, however, one crucial difference between cisgender and transgender women: "Women are fighting against their domestication and for trans women it's almost the other way around, they're fighting for a place at home. They're fighting to stay with their families, to not have to be on the streets," Sadiq said.

And while trans women are a familiar sight in streets in Pakistan, "unfortunately they'll be begging, or whatever".

- 'Everybody can relate' -

The film's trans dancer character, Biba, is played by Alina Khan who is herself a transgender woman.

Through an NGO she auditioned, without being a professional actress, for a role in Sadiq's 2019 short film "Darling", got the part, and continued working with him.

"My character Biba and I share a similar struggle," Khan told AFP. "But Biba is angrier than I am."

Khan, who saw "Joyland" for the first time at the Cannes festival, said she felt proud and emotional during the screening.

"I tried to keep it together because I didn't want to make a mess, but the reception was overwhelming. Some people in the audience started crying and I then I couldn't help myself, so I cried, too," she said.

She expects the film to find a receptive audience once released in Pakistan.

"It's an ensemble film that deals with men, women, and gender politics and issues of various kinds that almost everybody can relate to," she said. "It's going to be interesting for the audience back home."

Khan said the film's main takeaway for transgender people was: "People from the trans community can do anything they want to do, just like any man or any woman".

E.Schneyder--NZN