Zürcher Nachrichten - Twitter's future uncertain as it faces messy breakup with Musk

EUR -
AED 4.05586
AFN 78.957999
ALL 100.898311
AMD 432.103575
ANG 1.976787
AOA 1011.467257
ARS 1186.363518
AUD 1.745311
AWG 1.9876
AZN 1.87643
BAM 1.954087
BBD 2.229261
BDT 134.152351
BGN 1.953772
BHD 0.416176
BIF 3231.505662
BMD 1.104222
BND 1.475286
BOB 7.629483
BRL 6.218939
BSD 1.104092
BTN 94.249929
BWP 15.279831
BYN 3.613147
BYR 21642.751059
BZD 2.217774
CAD 1.554408
CDF 3172.42966
CHF 0.948974
CLF 0.027324
CLP 1048.524856
CNY 8.040448
CNH 8.038129
COP 4593.508279
CRC 556.291423
CUC 1.104222
CUP 29.261883
CVE 112.685325
CZK 25.073542
DJF 196.242018
DKK 7.461626
DOP 69.679844
DZD 146.67643
EGP 55.864685
ERN 16.56333
ETB 143.214489
FJD 2.556163
FKP 0.851043
GBP 0.843768
GEL 3.036243
GGP 0.851043
GHS 17.114226
GIP 0.851043
GMD 79.700647
GNF 9552.382551
GTQ 8.501761
GYD 231.665029
HKD 8.588794
HNL 28.265775
HRK 7.532116
HTG 143.529041
HUF 406.090928
IDR 18458.911507
ILS 4.079763
IMP 0.851043
INR 94.359084
IQD 1444.115785
IRR 46487.940849
ISK 146.205374
JEP 0.851043
JMD 172.048419
JOD 0.782868
JPY 161.544354
KES 142.703072
KGS 95.724625
KHR 4416.637221
KMF 499.828456
KPW 993.859466
KRW 1614.714394
KWD 0.340458
KYD 0.918256
KZT 555.254064
LAK 23926.815484
LBP 98898.408728
LKR 325.208576
LRD 220.835956
LSL 20.718348
LTL 3.260481
LVL 0.667933
LYD 5.333615
MAD 10.588417
MDL 19.734571
MGA 5093.722724
MKD 62.808495
MMK 2318.263231
MNT 3857.553481
MOP 8.851802
MRU 43.954051
MUR 50.532927
MVR 17.051344
MWK 1914.764226
MXN 22.015209
MYR 4.917931
MZN 70.547731
NAD 20.718348
NGN 1695.145855
NIO 40.631533
NOK 11.410279
NPR 151.045304
NZD 1.908306
OMR 0.425097
PAB 1.104222
PEN 4.057104
PGK 4.511816
PHP 63.03804
PKR 309.312831
PLN 4.235968
PYG 8802.577006
QAR 4.018956
RON 5.057577
RSD 119.055982
RUB 93.022442
RWF 1568.577853
SAR 4.141096
SBD 9.385397
SCR 15.971898
SDG 662.498791
SEK 10.816804
SGD 1.481886
SHP 0.867745
SLE 25.120995
SLL 23154.984273
SOS 629.958048
SRD 40.437351
STD 22855.165835
SVC 9.662235
SYP 14357.86896
SZL 20.718348
THB 37.663888
TJS 12.043366
TMT 3.862166
TND 3.415945
TOP 2.659637
TRY 41.973454
TTD 7.466717
TWD 36.575064
TZS 2922.401324
UAH 45.631623
UGX 4025.831038
USD 1.104222
UYU 46.647638
UZS 14290.01376
VES 77.083414
VND 28344.064062
VUV 136.448042
WST 3.128076
XAF 666.437941
XAG 0.034564
XAU 0.000355
XCD 2.989452
XDR 0.831364
XOF 666.437941
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.534362
ZAR 20.709672
ZMK 9939.317211
ZMW 30.955568
ZWL 355.559031
  • CMSC

    -0.2400

    22.26

    -1.08%

  • RIO

    -1.4700

    58.43

    -2.52%

  • SCS

    -0.7200

    10.74

    -6.7%

  • BCC

    -7.4400

    94.63

    -7.86%

  • NGG

    3.6100

    69.39

    +5.2%

  • RBGPF

    -0.2800

    67.72

    -0.41%

  • BTI

    1.6700

    41.92

    +3.98%

  • BCE

    0.8400

    22.66

    +3.71%

  • JRI

    -0.2200

    12.82

    -1.72%

  • RYCEF

    0.0200

    9.8

    +0.2%

  • CMSD

    -0.1600

    22.67

    -0.71%

  • GSK

    1.3700

    39.01

    +3.51%

  • RELX

    0.4600

    51.44

    +0.89%

  • AZN

    1.7000

    73.92

    +2.3%

  • VOD

    0.2500

    9.37

    +2.67%

  • BP

    -2.4700

    31.34

    -7.88%

Twitter's future uncertain as it faces messy breakup with Musk
Twitter's future uncertain as it faces messy breakup with Musk / Photo: JIM WATSON - AFP/File

Twitter's future uncertain as it faces messy breakup with Musk

Courted and then jilted by the world's richest person, Twitter looks well positioned to win a court battle with Elon Musk over a $1 billion breakup fee and more -- but the company will not emerge unscathed.

Text size:

The entire saga has left observers baffled by what Wedbush analyst Dan Ives described as "one of the craziest business stories ever."

"I think it starts off as a circus show and it's ending as a circus show," Ives told AFP.

Musk, the founder of electric car company Tesla, sent a letter to Twitter on Friday saying he was pulling out of the controversial deal he made in April to buy the platform for $54.20 per share, or $44 billion in total.

But such merger agreements are "designed to prevent buyers from getting cold feet and deciding they want to walk away," explains Ann Lipton, a professor of law at Tulane University who specializes in corporate litigation.

Musk, who also heads SpaceX, has accused the social media giant of "false and misleading representations" about the number of fake accounts on its platform.

His lawyers also point to recent Twitter employee layoffs and hiring freezes, which they say are contrary to the company's obligation to continue operating normally.

Those arguments may be valid, but they do not merit pulling out of the deal, says Lipton, dismissing them as "nitpicky."

"It's not enough, unless he can show that the representations (about fake accounts) are not just false, but also that they dramatically call the fundamentals of the deal into question," she explains.

"Looks very much like Musk is legally wrong."

- 'Twitter would die off' -

That leaves the possibility that the multi-billionaire is actually trying to renegotiate the price down.

This tactic has been used successfully elsewhere, such as by LVMH: two years ago, the global luxury giant broke off a deal to acquire Tiffany before getting a discount.

But experts don't see how Musk and Twitter could agree on a different price at this point, given that the platform's stock has lost more than a quarter of its value since late April.

"Both have a lot to lose," Lipton points out.

If Twitter wins in court, the mercurial entrepreneur will, at a minimum, have to pay a few billion dollars in damages.

At worst, he could be forced to honor his commitment and buy Twitter at a price that has become exorbitant, while his fortune has melted down by tens of billions of dollars in recent months.

But though this would be a victory for shareholders, it would still leave Twitter in Musk's hands -- and his libertarian vision of absolute free speech is not aligned with that of many of the employees, users and advertisers on whom the platform's business model depends.

"Twitter is worse off than six months ago, but in the long run, it's better off without him," says Creative Strategies analyst Carolina Milanesi.

"It feels like a toy that a spoiled kid wants, but doesn't really know what to do with, so he would get bored of it, and not give it the attention it deserves, and forget it in a corner ... Twitter would die off slowly and painfully," she predicts.

- 'Battle on all fronts' -

Any court proceedings are expected to last for months, especially since Musk "will drag it out," according to Lipton.

"Twitter is in a strong position," she says.

But Musk, followed by more than 100 million people on the platform, "will try to embarrass them -- it will be distracting and demoralizing for employees," she argues.

He has already harassed the platform with highly critical tweets, mockery and outlandish suggestions, encouraged by his many fans.

For Twitter, "it's going be a battle on all fronts -- keeping employees, competitors going after their business, brand issues, investors believing the numbers," says Ives, the Wedbush analyst.

Unlike its Silicon Valley neighbors, Twitter has never been a money-making machine, able to turn users' attention into astronomical advertising revenues.

"The past few months have been a huge distraction for Twitter, keeping it from focusing on its business fundamentals," notes Debra Williamson of eMarketer.

"If Musk is able to terminate the deal, Twitter will still be left with the same problems it had before he came on the scene," she says.

"Its user growth is slowing. And while ad revenue is still growing marginally, Twitter is now dealing with a slowing economy that could squeeze ad spending on all social platforms."

I.Widmer--NZN