Zürcher Nachrichten - Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

EUR -
AED 3.829665
AFN 73.124937
ALL 98.671597
AMD 412.950691
ANG 1.876092
AOA 950.893358
ARS 1066.519947
AUD 1.66985
AWG 1.876763
AZN 1.768751
BAM 1.958611
BBD 2.101816
BDT 124.398516
BGN 1.961207
BHD 0.392199
BIF 3078.217348
BMD 1.042646
BND 1.41453
BOB 7.193323
BRL 6.648748
BSD 1.040994
BTN 88.610159
BWP 14.457747
BYN 3.406689
BYR 20435.86617
BZD 2.094706
CAD 1.495833
CDF 2992.39459
CHF 0.923263
CLF 0.037382
CLP 1031.479634
CNY 7.609756
CNH 7.617798
COP 4580.720255
CRC 528.5585
CUC 1.042646
CUP 27.630125
CVE 110.423461
CZK 25.213254
DJF 185.376021
DKK 7.479841
DOP 63.410997
DZD 140.599492
EGP 52.925809
ERN 15.639693
ETB 132.543204
FJD 2.417532
FKP 0.825757
GBP 0.831489
GEL 2.929895
GGP 0.825757
GHS 15.301959
GIP 0.825757
GMD 75.070472
GNF 8996.910876
GTQ 8.018507
GYD 217.79254
HKD 8.098958
HNL 26.448955
HRK 7.478803
HTG 136.11533
HUF 412.012008
IDR 16871.162963
ILS 3.805904
IMP 0.825757
INR 89.0337
IQD 1363.656894
IRR 43882.378225
ISK 145.500924
JEP 0.825757
JMD 162.192752
JOD 0.739547
JPY 164.035366
KES 134.543357
KGS 90.709698
KHR 4184.00419
KMF 486.003444
KPW 938.381027
KRW 1518.620823
KWD 0.321323
KYD 0.867545
KZT 539.283891
LAK 22765.669517
LBP 93219.873719
LKR 306.800269
LRD 189.461884
LSL 19.356377
LTL 3.078663
LVL 0.630686
LYD 5.110334
MAD 10.497765
MDL 19.206562
MGA 4910.046085
MKD 61.524778
MMK 3386.474294
MNT 3542.911765
MOP 8.327751
MRU 41.555634
MUR 49.07729
MVR 16.078621
MWK 1805.090367
MXN 21.047639
MYR 4.678398
MZN 66.628983
NAD 19.356377
NGN 1606.884965
NIO 38.304969
NOK 11.839112
NPR 141.776454
NZD 1.846977
OMR 0.400329
PAB 1.040994
PEN 3.876363
PGK 4.225063
PHP 61.161284
PKR 289.809186
PLN 4.272871
PYG 8118.650542
QAR 3.786033
RON 4.988333
RSD 116.996577
RUB 103.976124
RWF 1452.183934
SAR 3.914406
SBD 8.741082
SCR 14.865032
SDG 627.148703
SEK 11.552916
SGD 1.408193
SHP 0.825757
SLE 23.765491
SLL 21863.773344
SOS 594.953779
SRD 36.553098
STD 21580.671932
SVC 9.109072
SYP 2619.680194
SZL 19.364789
THB 35.543468
TJS 11.388343
TMT 3.659688
TND 3.319263
TOP 2.441978
TRY 36.689814
TTD 7.074152
TWD 34.098599
TZS 2523.812801
UAH 43.648437
UGX 3810.468153
USD 1.042646
UYU 46.336494
UZS 13439.285837
VES 53.775059
VND 26514.493709
VUV 123.785049
WST 2.88061
XAF 656.899674
XAG 0.035236
XAU 0.000398
XCD 2.817804
XDR 0.798145
XOF 656.899674
XPF 119.331742
YER 261.052517
ZAR 19.454142
ZMK 9385.066686
ZMW 28.809342
ZWL 335.731662
  • RELX

    0.3000

    45.89

    +0.65%

  • BCC

    0.9500

    123.19

    +0.77%

  • SCS

    0.0800

    11.73

    +0.68%

  • NGG

    -0.1600

    58.86

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    7.24

    -0.14%

  • VOD

    0.0600

    8.43

    +0.71%

  • RIO

    -0.0300

    59.2

    -0.05%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    12.15

    +0.41%

  • RBGPF

    59.8000

    59.8

    +100%

  • CMSC

    -0.1321

    23.77

    -0.56%

  • BCE

    0.0600

    22.9

    +0.26%

  • GSK

    -0.0300

    34.03

    -0.09%

  • BTI

    0.0400

    36.26

    +0.11%

  • BP

    0.0400

    28.79

    +0.14%

  • AZN

    -0.3300

    66.3

    -0.5%

  • CMSD

    0.1000

    23.65

    +0.42%

Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?
Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

As digital objects in the form of NFTs have exploded in popularity and value over the past year, so too have the legal headaches and complications.

Text size:

Nike became the latest company to file a lawsuit over the issue on Thursday -- suing shopping platform StockX for creating and marketing NFTs with its logo and branding.

It follows a lawsuit last month by French luxury brand Hermes against artist Mason Rothschild, who has auctioned 100 "MetaBirkins" -- a digital "homage" to the label's famous Birkin bag -- some fetching tens of thousands of dollars.

- Can these cases succeed?

The Hermes case could go either way, said lawyer Annabelle Gauberti, whose firm Crefovi specialises in creative industries.

Rothschild has argued that he is protected by the First Amendment as an artist, which often has validity in US courts.

In Europe, too: Gauberti recalled the example of a case from a decade ago in which Louis Vuitton lost in its attempts to prevent a Dutch artist placing one of its bags in a picture of a Darfur refugee.

"The 'fair use' defence works well, particularly in UK and US law, in which an artist can use a trademarked word or product to make a point or as a parody," Gauberti said.

But she said Rothschild may struggle to convince a judge that his work had artistic merit.

"It's hard to see on the face of it what message he is trying to convey other than that he wants to make a lot of money, so it's going to be a lot of work for his legal team," she said.

The Nike case is a more directly commercial affair, since StockX has never claimed its NFTs are a form of art.

But it remains to be seen how trademark law holds up in the digital realm.

"The extent of these protections in the digital world as well as what remedies can be granted are yet to be explored," wrote lawyer Danielle Garno in a briefing note for Lexology.

- Should NFTs be treated differently to physical art?

In his response to Hermes, published on Twitter, Rothschild compared his MetaBirkins to Andy Warhol's famous Campbell soup paintings.

"The fact that I sell the art using NFTs doesn't change the fact that it's art," he wrote in a response published on Twitter.

However, Edward Lee of Chicago-Kent College of Law told Bloomberg Law that the Warhol comparison was not perfect since the Campbell Soup Co. was never likely to get into the business of selling paintings, whereas Hermes could well choose to create its own NFTs.

The technology can also confuse matters, since an NFT is actually just a receipt of ownership, rather than the thing itself.

"Many people assume that, when you talk about an NFT, the content of the NFT is inside the token, which it is not, and because it is not, there is no unauthorised reproduction," Primavera De Filippi, co-author of "Blockchain and the Law", told Business of Fashion magazine.

- What can companies do to protect themselves? -

Hermes has demanded that Rothschild remove and destroy his MetaBirkins, and at least one NFT platform, OpenSea, has already agreed to remove them from sale.

But Gauberti said enforcing the law online is very tricky.

"Even if lawsuits are successful, how do you go after the guy who has already bought the item or stop them being sold on secondary auctions? It's the wild west in terms of enforcement online," she said.

The best option, she said, is for brands to get ahead of the copycats and dominate the space with "official" NFTs.

Nike has done exactly that, acquiring RTFKT, a company that specialises in designing digital sneakers, in December.

"A strong offence is the best defence," said Gauberti.

"At the moment, a lot of these brands are on the fence (about creating their own NFTs) because their core products are physical, and they're still watching the space to see if the metaverse will really take off."

A.Ferraro--NZN