Zürcher Nachrichten - Dreaming the impossible dream: the 1.5C climate target

EUR -
AED 4.101345
AFN 77.032505
ALL 99.346177
AMD 432.43567
ANG 2.013049
AOA 1036.77807
ARS 1075.022084
AUD 1.638665
AWG 2.009927
AZN 1.903727
BAM 1.957678
BBD 2.255263
BDT 133.478024
BGN 1.96194
BHD 0.420821
BIF 3237.947656
BMD 1.116626
BND 1.443284
BOB 7.718265
BRL 6.064287
BSD 1.116971
BTN 93.354568
BWP 14.765294
BYN 3.655406
BYR 21885.869656
BZD 2.251419
CAD 1.514765
CDF 3205.83349
CHF 0.948568
CLF 0.037681
CLP 1039.724056
CNY 7.877914
CNH 7.876551
COP 4648.301891
CRC 579.545486
CUC 1.116626
CUP 29.590589
CVE 110.369377
CZK 25.076404
DJF 198.897208
DKK 7.459169
DOP 67.044305
DZD 147.724424
EGP 54.187291
ERN 16.74939
ETB 129.612896
FJD 2.456911
FKP 0.850377
GBP 0.839089
GEL 3.048765
GGP 0.850377
GHS 17.559528
GIP 0.850377
GMD 76.478493
GNF 9650.126208
GTQ 8.634359
GYD 233.659928
HKD 8.702442
HNL 27.707575
HRK 7.591952
HTG 147.378717
HUF 393.677561
IDR 16934.414972
ILS 4.208201
IMP 0.850377
INR 93.284779
IQD 1463.20342
IRR 47001.617801
ISK 152.296414
JEP 0.850377
JMD 175.488318
JOD 0.791351
JPY 161.091169
KES 144.067258
KGS 94.062898
KHR 4536.351005
KMF 492.822874
KPW 1004.96277
KRW 1492.18639
KWD 0.340616
KYD 0.930801
KZT 535.514042
LAK 24664.21472
LBP 100022.944684
LKR 340.786863
LRD 223.390262
LSL 19.608883
LTL 3.297107
LVL 0.675436
LYD 5.304278
MAD 10.830976
MDL 19.490869
MGA 5051.754868
MKD 61.661441
MMK 3626.7577
MNT 3794.295108
MOP 8.965839
MRU 44.388973
MUR 51.230572
MVR 17.151745
MWK 1936.622809
MXN 21.621786
MYR 4.695396
MZN 71.296513
NAD 19.608708
NGN 1830.652829
NIO 41.108877
NOK 11.731586
NPR 149.370267
NZD 1.791604
OMR 0.429846
PAB 1.116951
PEN 4.186559
PGK 4.37235
PHP 62.154728
PKR 310.35047
PLN 4.275394
PYG 8714.358307
QAR 4.072206
RON 4.974455
RSD 117.081921
RUB 103.595912
RWF 1505.75772
SAR 4.190263
SBD 9.275742
SCR 15.20849
SDG 671.658527
SEK 11.379804
SGD 1.442608
SHP 0.850377
SLE 25.511892
SLL 23415.083225
SOS 638.317954
SRD 33.334619
STD 23111.9038
SVC 9.773243
SYP 2805.55626
SZL 19.61599
THB 36.878746
TJS 11.873175
TMT 3.908191
TND 3.384446
TOP 2.615244
TRY 38.089784
TTD 7.597151
TWD 35.731768
TZS 3046.939603
UAH 46.168836
UGX 4138.117278
USD 1.116626
UYU 46.153648
UZS 14213.632892
VEF 4045036.356711
VES 41.049924
VND 27474.582801
VUV 132.568082
WST 3.12372
XAF 656.574989
XAG 0.035614
XAU 0.000427
XCD 3.017737
XDR 0.827794
XOF 656.577931
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.519396
ZAR 19.564743
ZMK 10050.970555
ZMW 29.570833
ZWL 359.553117
  • RBGPF

    3.5000

    60.5

    +5.79%

  • CMSC

    0.0650

    25.12

    +0.26%

  • JRI

    -0.0700

    13.33

    -0.53%

  • BCC

    -2.2400

    142.45

    -1.57%

  • RIO

    -0.7400

    64.44

    -1.15%

  • NGG

    0.6300

    69.46

    +0.91%

  • GSK

    -0.4400

    41.18

    -1.07%

  • SCS

    -0.2500

    13.06

    -1.91%

  • CMSD

    0.0300

    25.01

    +0.12%

  • AZN

    -0.5300

    78.37

    -0.68%

  • RELX

    -0.0100

    48.12

    -0.02%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0200

    6.93

    -0.29%

  • BCE

    0.0100

    35.2

    +0.03%

  • BP

    -0.1900

    32.57

    -0.58%

  • VOD

    -0.0150

    10.045

    -0.15%

  • BTI

    -0.1900

    37.38

    -0.51%

Dreaming the impossible dream: the 1.5C climate target
Dreaming the impossible dream: the 1.5C climate target / Photo: PATRICK KOVARIK - AFP/File

Dreaming the impossible dream: the 1.5C climate target

In the realm of climate diplomacy, it's the little engine that could, the 80-to-1-odds Kentucky Derby winner, the low-budget multiverse fantasy that came out of nowhere to sweep the Oscars.

Text size:

We are talking, of course, about the Paris Agreement goal of capping Earth's average surface temperature at 1.5 degrees Celsius above levels in the late 19th century, when burning fossil fuels began to seriously heat up the planet.

At barely 1.2C above that threshold, the world today has already seen a crescendo of deadly and destructive extreme weather.

Fifteen years ago, a 1.5C limit on global warming -- championed by small island nations worried about sea level rise -- was rejected by most scientists as unrealistic and by most countries as unnecessary.

A 2C "guardrail" was assumed to be safe enough.

Today, the 1.5C target is enshrined in everything, everywhere, all at once. While technically no more than an "aspirational" goal, it has become the de facto North Star for UN climate talks, national climate plans and the business world.

From Apple and Facebook to Big Pharma and even Big Oil, multinationals have unveiled promises and plans to be "1.5C-aligned", even if most of those plans don't hold up very well under scrutiny.

You can draw a straight line from 1.5C to the science-base imperative to nearly halve global emissions by 2030 and achieve net zero around mid-century, meaning any residual carbon pollution must be offset by removals.

Both of these targets are set to be affirmed in a report summarising six years of climate science, released Monday by the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

- 2C not good enough -

This raises a perplexing question, according to Beatrice Cointe, a sociologist at France's National Centre for Scientific Research and co-author of a recent study on the history of the 1.5C target.

"How did an almost impossible target become the point of reference for climate action?" she asked.

And what will happen when the world experiences its first full year at or above 1.5C, which the IPCC says could easily happen within a decade, even under aggressive emissions reduction scenarios?

"The target appears increasingly unattainable," Cointe and co-author Helene Guillemot, a historian of science at the Centre Alexandre-Koyre, wrote in the journal WIREs Climate Change.

"And yet calls to 'Keep 1.5C Alive' have been growing louder."

The backstory of the 1.5C goal reveals an interplay of science and politics, with one driving and shaping the other.

Going into the 2015 climate negotiations that yielded the breakthrough Paris treaty, it seemed unlikely that 195 nations would significantly improve on the 2C target already set in stone.

But a scientific evaluation by a UN technical body delivered ahead of the December summit sounded an alarm about the dangers of a +2C world and suggested greater ambition might be wise.

"While science on the 1.5C limit is less robust, efforts should be made to push the defence line as low as possible," it concluded.

A growing coalition of developing nations, meanwhile, had gathered behind the 1.5C goal, eventually joined by the European Union and the United States.

Emerging giants and oil exporters baulked, fearful of the constraints on their fossil-fuel dependent economies.

"China was against it, India was against it, Saudi Arabia fought us tooth-and-nail to the very end," recalled Saleemul Huq, director of the International Centre for Climate Change and Development in Dhaka.

Even today, these nations remain lukewarm on the idea.

But in the end, nearly 200 nations committed to cap warming at "well below 2C", while "pursuing effort to limit the temperature increase to 1.5C."

- 'A moral target' -

It was a stunning diplomatic coup. Many scientists, however, were less than thrilled.

"It will be very hard -- if not impossible -- to keep warming below 1.5 C during the entire 21st century," Joeri Rogelj, a climate modeller currently at Imperial College London who played a key role in the technical report, told AFP at the time.

But because the target was part of the Paris Agreement, nations called on the IPCC -- which exists to brief policymakers on climate science -- for a "special report".

The resulting bombshell, delivered in October 2018, left no doubt as to the difference a half-a-degree makes: a 1.5C world will see deep change but remain liveable; a 2C world could tip the climate system into overdrive, outstripping our capacity to adapt, it warned.

Today, the IPCC -- including Rogelj, a lead author of the 2018 report -- insists that the 1.5C goal is technically feasible.

But that conclusion hangs by the thinnest of threads.

There is no scenario that avoids "overshooting" the target, and bringing temperatures back under the wire will require extracting billions of tonnes of CO2 from thin air, something we can't do yet at scale.

But whether the 1.5C target is feasible may be missing the point, say others.

"Getting 1.5 C into the agreement was a moral target," Huq told AFP not long after the Paris pact was inked.

"It's our leverage, the whip we will use to hit everybody on the back so they can go faster," he added.

"Whether we achieve it or not is going down a dark track. From now on, it's about raising ambition."

Piers Forster, director of the University of Leeds Priestley International Centre for Climate and a coordinating lead author for the IPCC, describes the 1.5C objective as a "huge, but not impossible, task".

"Hopefully the IPCC report can push the urgency," he told AFP. "If it's ignored, we would have to give up on 1.5C."

F.E.Ackermann--NZN