Zürcher Nachrichten - What next for Macron after election humbling?

EUR -
AED 3.896071
AFN 72.130551
ALL 98.649047
AMD 412.597671
ANG 1.911906
AOA 968.990719
ARS 1062.604762
AUD 1.621287
AWG 1.903478
AZN 1.780298
BAM 1.964381
BBD 2.141956
BDT 126.773765
BGN 1.957762
BHD 0.399798
BIF 3074.564963
BMD 1.060743
BND 1.421148
BOB 7.357346
BRL 6.123093
BSD 1.060864
BTN 89.589875
BWP 14.433046
BYN 3.471665
BYR 20790.572112
BZD 2.138401
CAD 1.480024
CDF 3044.33428
CHF 0.935507
CLF 0.037339
CLP 1030.289842
CNY 7.678083
CNH 7.672236
COP 4659.199033
CRC 539.270862
CUC 1.060743
CUP 28.109702
CVE 110.980299
CZK 25.286428
DJF 188.514852
DKK 7.45915
DOP 64.161703
DZD 141.327807
EGP 52.558249
ERN 15.911152
ETB 130.073716
FJD 2.400479
FKP 0.837263
GBP 0.835611
GEL 2.911696
GGP 0.837263
GHS 16.865687
GIP 0.837263
GMD 74.766985
GNF 9154.216134
GTQ 8.190007
GYD 221.839024
HKD 8.25617
HNL 26.714829
HRK 7.566558
HTG 139.358738
HUF 408.365365
IDR 16816.602757
ILS 3.971153
IMP 0.837263
INR 89.531682
IQD 1390.104324
IRR 44662.603968
ISK 145.470125
JEP 0.837263
JMD 168.254961
JOD 0.752387
JPY 164.049282
KES 137.382069
KGS 91.758976
KHR 4296.011351
KMF 493.007062
KPW 954.668725
KRW 1474.465045
KWD 0.326115
KYD 0.884062
KZT 526.424383
LAK 23283.319803
LBP 94989.578538
LKR 308.648218
LRD 191.729793
LSL 19.17825
LTL 3.1321
LVL 0.641633
LYD 5.165982
MAD 10.580883
MDL 19.280219
MGA 4947.307016
MKD 61.534621
MMK 3445.25343
MNT 3604.406271
MOP 8.50475
MRU 42.339519
MUR 49.091221
MVR 16.388592
MWK 1841.450534
MXN 21.326964
MYR 4.736175
MZN 67.845196
NAD 19.236822
NGN 1781.359402
NIO 39.038261
NOK 11.637273
NPR 143.344201
NZD 1.791736
OMR 0.408407
PAB 1.060864
PEN 4.025533
PGK 4.209134
PHP 62.458169
PKR 295.019325
PLN 4.332435
PYG 8262.089959
QAR 3.861902
RON 4.97616
RSD 116.965016
RUB 106.685326
RWF 1454.279304
SAR 3.982147
SBD 8.877913
SCR 14.446549
SDG 638.035263
SEK 11.570993
SGD 1.417647
SHP 0.837263
SLE 23.97887
SLL 22243.265325
SOS 606.208915
SRD 37.697234
STD 21955.248302
SVC 9.282547
SYP 2665.149653
SZL 19.178561
THB 36.606089
TJS 11.276658
TMT 3.72321
TND 3.338689
TOP 2.484371
TRY 36.586825
TTD 7.20367
TWD 34.304975
TZS 2815.194113
UAH 43.79671
UGX 3906.062223
USD 1.060743
UYU 45.53892
UZS 13651.768587
VES 48.565083
VND 26948.187985
VUV 125.933597
WST 2.961162
XAF 658.853598
XAG 0.033896
XAU 0.000402
XCD 2.866712
XDR 0.806925
XOF 656.069696
XPF 119.331742
YER 265.081451
ZAR 19.13194
ZMK 9547.967398
ZMW 29.306845
ZWL 341.558966
  • RBGPF

    -0.4400

    59.75

    -0.74%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1600

    6.69

    -2.39%

  • NGG

    0.6800

    63.58

    +1.07%

  • CMSC

    -0.0590

    24.565

    -0.24%

  • CMSD

    -0.0460

    24.344

    -0.19%

  • RIO

    0.3100

    62.43

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    0.0000

    8.92

    0%

  • BTI

    0.2500

    36.93

    +0.68%

  • SCS

    -0.1100

    13.09

    -0.84%

  • JRI

    0.0300

    13.26

    +0.23%

  • GSK

    -0.2300

    33.46

    -0.69%

  • BCC

    -3.3600

    138.18

    -2.43%

  • RELX

    0.2500

    45.29

    +0.55%

  • BCE

    0.0800

    27.31

    +0.29%

  • AZN

    0.4100

    63.8

    +0.64%

  • BP

    -0.3300

    29.09

    -1.13%

What next for Macron after election humbling?
What next for Macron after election humbling? / Photo: Ludovic MARIN - AFP

What next for Macron after election humbling?

Just two months after being re-elected for a second term, French President Emmanuel Macron saw his hopes of pushing through his domestic agenda take a humbling blow on Sunday. What comes next?

Text size:

His allies, known together as "Ensemble" (Together), looked on track to finish as the biggest party in parliament with 210-260 MPs, but far short of the 289 needed for a majority.

This scenario is extremely rare under modern France's presidential regime, even before a constitutional change in 2002 which was intended to make it easier for the head of state to secure a parliamentary majority.

The election will not affect French foreign policy in theory, which is the exclusive domain of the president, but Macron's domestic worries are likely to be a constant distraction and could undermine him abroad.

Here are the possible scenarios:

- Form an alliance -

Work on this will begin on Monday morning, Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne vowed in a short speech on Sunday night.

In the middle of the biggest cost-of-living crisis in a generation, the ruling party was in a rush to pass an emergency bill to help low-income families before the summer holidays in August.

That along with other key parts of Macron's manifesto -- such as welfare reform or raising the retirement age -- will require the support of allies in the National Assembly.

"Together" is seen as most likely to reach out to France's traditional rightwing party, the Republicans (LR) and its centre-right ally UDI, which are on course for 55-77 seats, projections showed.

"We are going to form a majority very quickly," said Olivier Veran, minister in charge of parliamentary relations, sounding an optimistic note.

Economy Minister Bruno Le Maire said that the ruling party would need "a lot of imagination" and he called on parties which shared Macron's "clear ideas" to support him.

Although some inside LR are known to be in favour of working with Macron, including former president Nicolas Sarkozy, party head Christian Jacob ruled it out on Sunday.

"As far as we are concerned, we campaigned as an opposition party, we are in the opposition and we will stay in opposition," he said.

But is this a negotiating tactic, perhaps to attract offers of ministerial posts and other concessions?

If an alliance were formed, Macron would have to shift rightwards, but might be able to push through his cherished tax cuts, welfare and pension reform.

- Bill-by-bill negotiations -

In the absence of a formal alliance, the minority government will need to rely on support from opposition parties for each piece of legislation.

This will require long negotiations before each bill is brought to a vote -- and leaves the government vulnerable to last-minute withdrawals that could lead to defeat.

Again, the Republicans will be key, given that support from the hard-left NUPES alliance or the far-right National Rally will be ruled out.

"You can govern with a minority so long as the opposition parties do not join forces against you," Dominique Rousseau, a constitutional law expert at the Paris Pantheon-Sorbonne University, told AFP.

Socialist Prime Minister Michel Rocard headed a minority left-wing government from 1988-1991 after gains by the right in parliamentary elections in 1988.

"It was hell," his cabinet director Jean-Paul Huchon was quoted as saying in Le Point magazine recently.

Borne is expected to go before the new parliament in the coming weeks to give her first speech and will face a highly uncertain confidence vote which could bring her down.

Even if the low-key career civil servant passes that test, she will be constantly vulnerable to a censureship motion that will bring down the government.

To pass legislation, the French constitution does give Macron a tool to force through bills, article 49.3 of the constitution.

This enables the prime minister to ram legislation through without any parliamentary debate, but it can also be overturned if a majority opposes it within 24 hours of its use, and can only be used once every parliamentary session.

"Ungovernable" said the headline of a column in Les Echos newspaper.

- New elections -

As a final resort, if the parliament remains deadlocked and no stable government can be formed, Macron has one other option: dissolving the assembly and calling new elections.

But the outcome of this would be highly uncertain, with anger growing about inflation and support increasing for anti-establishment parties such as Melenchon's France Unbowed and Le Pen's National Rally.

Much would depend on whom voters blamed for the deadlock.

A.P.Huber--NZN