Zürcher Nachrichten - In Ukraine, war raises spectre of devastating Stalin-era famine

EUR -
AED 3.888366
AFN 72.007736
ALL 98.044838
AMD 410.170574
ANG 1.901073
AOA 967.064771
ARS 1060.501272
AUD 1.623064
AWG 1.899709
AZN 1.799366
BAM 1.953279
BBD 2.129871
BDT 126.057292
BGN 1.952224
BHD 0.398909
BIF 3115.508099
BMD 1.058644
BND 1.413089
BOB 7.315557
BRL 6.111442
BSD 1.054853
BTN 89.081019
BWP 14.351679
BYN 3.452077
BYR 20749.413776
BZD 2.126276
CAD 1.477893
CDF 3038.306822
CHF 0.935492
CLF 0.037265
CLP 1028.250492
CNY 7.665958
CNH 7.668062
COP 4649.975387
CRC 536.21295
CUC 1.058644
CUP 28.054054
CVE 110.122859
CZK 25.290778
DJF 187.839321
DKK 7.46006
DOP 63.528601
DZD 141.060489
EGP 52.416091
ERN 15.879653
ETB 129.830375
FJD 2.398994
FKP 0.835605
GBP 0.834698
GEL 2.906005
GGP 0.835605
GHS 16.803311
GIP 0.835605
GMD 74.638017
GNF 9091.351252
GTQ 8.143489
GYD 220.58528
HKD 8.239132
HNL 26.653101
HRK 7.551579
HTG 138.572447
HUF 408.38209
IDR 16798.661875
ILS 3.961799
IMP 0.835605
INR 89.326542
IQD 1381.816426
IRR 44574.187371
ISK 145.478712
JEP 0.835605
JMD 167.30721
JOD 0.750892
JPY 164.392513
KES 136.756692
KGS 91.570837
KHR 4284.510257
KMF 492.03104
KPW 952.778803
KRW 1472.562789
KWD 0.325491
KYD 0.879065
KZT 523.434379
LAK 23128.365625
LBP 94461.666267
LKR 306.90676
LRD 191.984916
LSL 19.069364
LTL 3.1259
LVL 0.640363
LYD 5.145407
MAD 10.539296
MDL 19.171436
MGA 4930.705575
MKD 61.505577
MMK 3438.432988
MNT 3597.27076
MOP 8.456685
MRU 41.982208
MUR 49.00302
MVR 16.355939
MWK 1829.16493
MXN 21.311908
MYR 4.732364
MZN 67.710251
NAD 19.071883
NGN 1773.0268
NIO 38.82026
NOK 11.63931
NPR 142.531375
NZD 1.793263
OMR 0.407598
PAB 1.054838
PEN 4.003133
PGK 4.244561
PHP 62.354952
PKR 293.143779
PLN 4.334194
PYG 8215.473514
QAR 3.847034
RON 4.976048
RSD 116.96761
RUB 105.599193
RWF 1450.954598
SAR 3.974354
SBD 8.860338
SCR 14.906727
SDG 636.775466
SEK 11.569524
SGD 1.417783
SHP 0.835605
SLE 23.923391
SLL 22199.231145
SOS 602.833284
SRD 37.622602
STD 21911.784299
SVC 9.230086
SYP 2659.873554
SZL 19.06666
THB 36.597095
TJS 11.212927
TMT 3.715839
TND 3.32371
TOP 2.479452
TRY 36.568349
TTD 7.162755
TWD 34.39586
TZS 2803.250008
UAH 43.549805
UGX 3883.986759
USD 1.058644
UYU 45.281553
UZS 13528.538093
VES 48.468632
VND 26905.426078
VUV 125.684291
WST 2.9553
XAF 655.120688
XAG 0.034088
XAU 0.000402
XCD 2.861037
XDR 0.802376
XOF 655.120688
XPF 119.331742
YER 264.549116
ZAR 19.145913
ZMK 9529.097509
ZMW 29.140662
ZWL 340.882794
  • RBGPF

    59.6500

    59.65

    +100%

  • CMSD

    -0.0460

    24.344

    -0.19%

  • RIO

    0.3100

    62.43

    +0.5%

  • NGG

    0.6800

    63.58

    +1.07%

  • JRI

    0.0300

    13.26

    +0.23%

  • SCS

    -0.1100

    13.09

    -0.84%

  • BCC

    -3.3600

    138.18

    -2.43%

  • CMSC

    -0.0590

    24.565

    -0.24%

  • BCE

    0.0800

    27.31

    +0.29%

  • GSK

    -0.2300

    33.46

    -0.69%

  • RELX

    0.2500

    45.29

    +0.55%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0700

    6.62

    -1.06%

  • AZN

    0.4100

    63.8

    +0.64%

  • VOD

    0.0000

    8.92

    0%

  • BTI

    0.2500

    36.93

    +0.68%

  • BP

    -0.3300

    29.09

    -1.13%

In Ukraine, war raises spectre of devastating Stalin-era famine
In Ukraine, war raises spectre of devastating Stalin-era famine / Photo: SERGEY BOBOK - AFP

In Ukraine, war raises spectre of devastating Stalin-era famine

For Maria Goncharova, a 93-year-old survivor of the devastating famine that hit Ukraine in the 1930s, Russia's invasion has awoken fears that the nightmare of starvation could happen again.

Text size:

Scarred for life by Stalin's campaign of forced "collectivisation", when seized grain and other foodstuffs left millions to starve, this elderly lady still hoards everything for fear of going without.

Since the Russian invasion began, the skies over her small pale blue house in Cheremushna, a village in the eastern Kharkiv region, have been filled with missiles, the war bringing back some awful memories.

"We only survived by cooking a potato and some flour each day," says Goncharova, a red scarf covering her hair, who has three chickens in her small garden.

Her tiny monthly pension of 2,000 hryvnia (65 euros/$68) means every penny counts, with everything cooked on her wood-fired stove.

The Russians "have already stolen a lot of grain from us and they are capable of taking everything," she sighs, crossing herself.

- The Holodomor -

Known as the "Holodomor" -- Ukrainian for "death by starvation" -- the 1932-1933 famine is regarded by Kyiv as a deliberate act of genocide by Stalin's regime with the intention of wiping out the peasantry.

"Food was used by the Soviet authorities to achieve their objectives by killing those who were resisting their authority on a large scale," said Lyudmyla Grynevych, a historian who heads the Holodomor research and education centre.

The Holodomor has long been a major sticking point in ties between Russia and Ukraine.

Moscow rejects Kyiv's narrative, placing the events in the broader context of famines that devastated regions of Central Asia and Russia.

And the current conflict has only fuelled fears that history may repeat itself, with Russia's targeting of grain storage facilities and its blockade of Ukraine's Black Sea exports sparking accusations that Moscow is once again using food as a weapon of war.

European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen raised the allegation at Davos and earlier this month, Andriy Yermak, head of the Ukrainian presidency, accused Russia of "trying to recreate the Holodomor" through its shelling of agricultural areas.

"The 1930s are very appropriate for drawing parallels because that was also an attempt to annihilate what we would call today the political entity that is Ukraine," says Grynevych.

"Ukrainians had their grain confiscated and starved to death, and then the Soviet authorities sent in some grain but only to those who agreed to join the kolkhozes," she said, referring to the huge Soviet agricultural cooperatives.

- A mark on every family -

Kharkiv, which lies more than 450 kilometres (280 miles) east of Kyiv, was the first capital of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic from 1919-1934.

At the time, the area was considered to be one of the top 23 most fertile regions in the entire Soviet Union.

Around Cheremushna village where Goncharova grew up, "a third of the residents died" during the famine, says Tamara Polishchuk, who runs a museum dedicated to the Holodomor.

But even then, not all deaths were registered as the process "was suspended", said Polishchuk, who has done extensive research into the subject.

For her, every family in the area is marked by the memory of the devastating famine that the USSR tried for decades to erase, and which Ukraine was only able to commemorate in its own right after independence in 1991.

Showing off the supplies she has put away, Goncharova proudly says she "still has a little bit of everything".

"Many countries help us. They bring us things and give it to the people. But only God knows how much longer it will continue," she says before going out to sit on her porch in the shade of a walnut tree.

A.Wyss--NZN