Zürcher Nachrichten - Asylum seekers: Return centres – a Solution?

EUR -
AED 3.87034
AFN 72.060444
ALL 98.019455
AMD 410.266765
ANG 1.900638
AOA 962.050251
ARS 1056.643043
AUD 1.615844
AWG 1.896703
AZN 1.786176
BAM 1.954213
BBD 2.12935
BDT 126.027635
BGN 1.957691
BHD 0.397134
BIF 3114.840446
BMD 1.053724
BND 1.416336
BOB 7.303068
BRL 6.108757
BSD 1.054633
BTN 88.969735
BWP 14.407161
BYN 3.451264
BYR 20652.99284
BZD 2.125753
CAD 1.471015
CDF 3018.919992
CHF 0.930159
CLF 0.037188
CLP 1026.137258
CNY 7.625384
CNH 7.630401
COP 4632.792948
CRC 535.557376
CUC 1.053724
CUP 27.923689
CVE 110.175511
CZK 25.313581
DJF 187.795683
DKK 7.458754
DOP 63.60743
DZD 140.648561
EGP 52.504121
ERN 15.805862
ETB 131.48603
FJD 2.391113
FKP 0.831722
GBP 0.833854
GEL 2.887504
GGP 0.831722
GHS 16.741402
GIP 0.831722
GMD 74.814294
GNF 9090.48695
GTQ 8.141387
GYD 220.640787
HKD 8.20065
HNL 26.649974
HRK 7.516487
HTG 138.536161
HUF 410.958709
IDR 16783.9286
ILS 3.933773
IMP 0.831722
INR 89.026621
IQD 1381.47791
IRR 44353.893119
ISK 145.508981
JEP 0.831722
JMD 167.162638
JOD 0.747193
JPY 162.514809
KES 136.453404
KGS 91.148384
KHR 4255.50313
KMF 492.618494
KPW 948.351313
KRW 1473.169608
KWD 0.324062
KYD 0.878886
KZT 523.884481
LAK 23157.190833
LBP 94448.988541
LKR 306.83078
LRD 190.883146
LSL 19.128163
LTL 3.111373
LVL 0.637387
LYD 5.145772
MAD 10.535443
MDL 19.19341
MGA 4936.943171
MKD 61.551012
MMK 3422.454853
MNT 3580.554518
MOP 8.455232
MRU 41.923351
MUR 49.019201
MVR 16.290976
MWK 1828.697307
MXN 21.391464
MYR 4.698532
MZN 67.385453
NAD 19.128163
NGN 1770.878557
NIO 38.80811
NOK 11.629158
NPR 142.349352
NZD 1.793651
OMR 0.405689
PAB 1.054543
PEN 4.002149
PGK 4.245491
PHP 62.160768
PKR 293.17419
PLN 4.351563
PYG 8259.213166
QAR 3.845776
RON 4.977058
RSD 116.998172
RUB 106.007636
RWF 1454.304956
SAR 3.955997
SBD 8.804425
SCR 14.351716
SDG 633.818744
SEK 11.588231
SGD 1.41354
SHP 0.831722
SLE 23.78781
SLL 22096.073019
SOS 602.70474
SRD 37.333471
STD 21809.961916
SVC 9.227505
SYP 2647.513325
SZL 19.117291
THB 36.454665
TJS 11.231377
TMT 3.688034
TND 3.328796
TOP 2.467928
TRY 36.377681
TTD 7.1402
TWD 34.270795
TZS 2797.488951
UAH 43.486366
UGX 3891.838898
USD 1.053724
UYU 45.083382
UZS 13544.998228
VES 48.472967
VND 26784.086658
VUV 125.100246
WST 2.941567
XAF 655.418424
XAG 0.033794
XAU 0.000395
XCD 2.847742
XDR 0.802441
XOF 655.418424
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.351972
ZAR 19.117559
ZMK 9484.792878
ZMW 29.186017
ZWL 339.298738
  • RBGPF

    59.6900

    59.69

    +100%

  • CMSC

    -0.0450

    24.52

    -0.18%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0800

    6.61

    -1.21%

  • CMSD

    -0.0836

    24.26

    -0.34%

  • SCS

    -0.0200

    13.07

    -0.15%

  • GSK

    -0.1100

    33.35

    -0.33%

  • AZN

    -0.6000

    63.2

    -0.95%

  • BTI

    0.1500

    37.08

    +0.4%

  • RELX

    -0.1800

    45.11

    -0.4%

  • RIO

    -0.0400

    62.39

    -0.06%

  • NGG

    -0.3100

    63.27

    -0.49%

  • VOD

    0.0200

    8.94

    +0.22%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    13.23

    -0.23%

  • BCE

    -0.3100

    27

    -1.15%

  • BP

    -0.0100

    29.08

    -0.03%

  • BCC

    -0.7700

    137.41

    -0.56%


Asylum seekers: Return centres – a Solution?




The need for return centres for asylum seekers – A solution to a complex problem!

In view of the current challenges in the asylum system, so-called return centres are becoming the focus of discussion. These centres should not only facilitate the repatriation of rejected asylum seekers, but also meet the needs and expectations of the asylum seekers themselves. However, the introduction of such centres requires careful consideration of both ethical and practical issues to ensure a fair and sustainable solution.

Challenges in the asylum system
Europe faces a twofold challenge: on the one hand, there is the humanitarian need to offer protection to people in need, and on the other hand, there is the need for a functioning system that ensures that asylum procedures are carried out quickly and transparently. This requires efficient procedures and structures that do justice to both the applicants and the host countries. An important instrument could be the establishment of return centres. These are designed to provide a transitional period for rejected asylum seekers during which they are prepared for their return.

What are return centres?
Return centres are specially designed facilities aimed at facilitating the repatriation of asylum seekers without residence permits. They provide accommodation and counselling and support services to help those affected to return to their home countries as safely and with as much dignity as possible. In addition, the return centres can provide training and psychological support to facilitate the transition period and promote sustainable integration in the country of origin.

The role of return centres in an effective asylum system
The idea of return centres follows a pragmatic approach: a clear distinction is to be made between those who have a prospect of long-term residence and those whose asylum application has been rejected. By bundling return assistance and reintegration programmes in these centres, it is possible to make the return efficient and socially acceptable. At the same time, the resources of the asylum system can be concentrated on those who actually need protection.
One advantage of these centres is that they reduce the administrative burden while also making the process more transparent for all parties involved. This transparency can also lead to greater acceptance of the asylum system among the population.

Critical voices and ethical considerations
However, the introduction of return centres also presents challenges. Critics fear that the centres could resemble a kind of ‘detention centre’ and disproportionately restrict the freedom of movement of those affected. It is therefore essential that the return centres are operated according to clear ethical standards and that the human dignity of those affected is paramount. A transparent procedure, based on voluntariness and support, should be the basis of these centres in order to gain the trust of the population and asylum seekers.

Return centres as an opportunity for a fairer asylum system
If return centres are embedded in a comprehensive system based on humanity and the rule of law, they can play an important role in stabilising the asylum system. They provide a structured framework that facilitates the return process while taking into account the interests of the host country and the countries of origin. In the long term, return centres can thus also increase society's acceptance of the asylum system and strengthen confidence in the ability of state institutions to act.

Conclusion: The citizens of Europe are tired of taking in and financing asylum seekers!
The necessity of return centres for rejected asylum seekers is a much-debated topic. Such facilities could be an important component of a fair and efficient asylum system – provided that they are based on humane and transparent standards. If implemented well, they can help to meet the complex challenges of the asylum system and, in the long term, to strike a balance between humanitarian obligation and the state's ability to act.