Zürcher Nachrichten - Asylum seekers: Return centres – a Solution?

EUR -
AED 3.897588
AFN 71.62565
ALL 97.2537
AMD 411.203272
ANG 1.913552
AOA 968.293905
ARS 1058.745012
AUD 1.627557
AWG 1.911648
AZN 1.807819
BAM 1.955455
BBD 2.143822
BDT 126.883565
BGN 1.95804
BHD 0.399961
BIF 3075.191117
BMD 1.061143
BND 1.421016
BOB 7.363046
BRL 6.140859
BSD 1.061762
BTN 89.662386
BWP 14.445129
BYN 3.47465
BYR 20798.394027
BZD 2.140123
CAD 1.480899
CDF 3044.418227
CHF 0.936171
CLF 0.037916
CLP 1046.211864
CNY 7.674607
COP 4713.329932
CRC 543.329624
CUC 1.061143
CUP 28.120278
CVE 110.729863
CZK 25.391006
DJF 188.586074
DKK 7.45901
DOP 63.933705
DZD 141.600995
EGP 52.213665
ETB 128.927564
FJD 2.404653
GBP 0.833113
GEL 2.907297
GHS 17.418672
GMD 75.870655
GNF 9158.721715
GTQ 8.204937
GYD 222.11867
HKD 8.254453
HNL 26.592299
HTG 139.651911
HUF 410.802767
IDR 16762.975014
ILS 3.985736
INR 89.551307
IQD 1390.096744
IRR 44679.406949
ISK 147.498979
JMD 168.710198
JOD 0.752456
JPY 164.232506
KES 137.417871
KGS 91.474118
KHR 4302.933102
KMF 488.523524
KRW 1494.624597
KWD 0.326418
KYD 0.884785
KZT 526.901752
LAK 23302.690344
LBP 95078.373015
LKR 310.479784
LRD 196.6824
LSL 19.280981
LTL 3.133278
LVL 0.641875
LYD 5.162473
MAD 10.527599
MDL 19.005538
MGA 4923.70171
MKD 61.609117
MMK 3446.549617
MOP 8.506897
MRU 42.335075
MUR 49.990475
MVR 16.405298
MWK 1841.082561
MXN 21.872228
MYR 4.708282
MZN 67.833584
NAD 19.281345
NGN 1774.951722
NIO 39.023514
NOK 11.770787
NPR 143.459418
NZD 1.793877
OMR 0.40856
PAB 1.061762
PEN 4.000181
PGK 4.260222
PHP 62.350627
PKR 295.050664
PLN 4.354234
PYG 8295.534619
QAR 3.863355
RON 4.976865
RSD 116.971889
RUB 104.249364
RWF 1445.806728
SAR 3.987149
SBD 8.850728
SCR 14.422986
SDG 638.273057
SEK 11.587852
SGD 1.421194
SLE 24.247182
SOS 605.912547
SRD 37.389344
STD 21963.508396
SVC 9.290797
SZL 18.707922
THB 36.991474
TJS 11.2858
TMT 3.72461
TND 3.339947
TOP 2.485304
TRY 36.467135
TTD 7.215065
TWD 34.443094
TZS 2824.618246
UAH 43.973732
UGX 3901.494647
USD 1.061143
UYU 44.764202
UZS 13614.459211
VES 47.430329
VND 26899.963703
XAF 655.872046
XCD 2.867791
XDR 0.799896
XOF 645.174431
XPF 119.331742
YER 265.099936
ZAR 19.251725
ZMK 9551.56176
ZMW 28.906256
ZWL 341.687469
  • CMSC

    -0.0700

    24.65

    -0.28%

  • RBGPF

    0.0300

    60.22

    +0.05%

  • RIO

    -1.6250

    60.975

    -2.67%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1700

    7.16

    -2.37%

  • NGG

    -1.0050

    63.135

    -1.59%

  • RELX

    -1.1500

    46.65

    -2.47%

  • SCS

    0.0900

    13.74

    +0.66%

  • GSK

    -0.8000

    35.55

    -2.25%

  • AZN

    0.6800

    65.47

    +1.04%

  • BTI

    0.1400

    35.29

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    -0.1650

    24.795

    -0.67%

  • VOD

    -0.8800

    8.44

    -10.43%

  • BP

    -0.6550

    28.265

    -2.32%

  • BCE

    -0.3200

    27.53

    -1.16%

  • BCC

    -1.0360

    142.104

    -0.73%

  • JRI

    -0.1200

    13.4

    -0.9%


Asylum seekers: Return centres – a Solution?




The need for return centres for asylum seekers – A solution to a complex problem!

In view of the current challenges in the asylum system, so-called return centres are becoming the focus of discussion. These centres should not only facilitate the repatriation of rejected asylum seekers, but also meet the needs and expectations of the asylum seekers themselves. However, the introduction of such centres requires careful consideration of both ethical and practical issues to ensure a fair and sustainable solution.

Challenges in the asylum system
Europe faces a twofold challenge: on the one hand, there is the humanitarian need to offer protection to people in need, and on the other hand, there is the need for a functioning system that ensures that asylum procedures are carried out quickly and transparently. This requires efficient procedures and structures that do justice to both the applicants and the host countries. An important instrument could be the establishment of return centres. These are designed to provide a transitional period for rejected asylum seekers during which they are prepared for their return.

What are return centres?
Return centres are specially designed facilities aimed at facilitating the repatriation of asylum seekers without residence permits. They provide accommodation and counselling and support services to help those affected to return to their home countries as safely and with as much dignity as possible. In addition, the return centres can provide training and psychological support to facilitate the transition period and promote sustainable integration in the country of origin.

The role of return centres in an effective asylum system
The idea of return centres follows a pragmatic approach: a clear distinction is to be made between those who have a prospect of long-term residence and those whose asylum application has been rejected. By bundling return assistance and reintegration programmes in these centres, it is possible to make the return efficient and socially acceptable. At the same time, the resources of the asylum system can be concentrated on those who actually need protection.
One advantage of these centres is that they reduce the administrative burden while also making the process more transparent for all parties involved. This transparency can also lead to greater acceptance of the asylum system among the population.

Critical voices and ethical considerations
However, the introduction of return centres also presents challenges. Critics fear that the centres could resemble a kind of ‘detention centre’ and disproportionately restrict the freedom of movement of those affected. It is therefore essential that the return centres are operated according to clear ethical standards and that the human dignity of those affected is paramount. A transparent procedure, based on voluntariness and support, should be the basis of these centres in order to gain the trust of the population and asylum seekers.

Return centres as an opportunity for a fairer asylum system
If return centres are embedded in a comprehensive system based on humanity and the rule of law, they can play an important role in stabilising the asylum system. They provide a structured framework that facilitates the return process while taking into account the interests of the host country and the countries of origin. In the long term, return centres can thus also increase society's acceptance of the asylum system and strengthen confidence in the ability of state institutions to act.

Conclusion: The citizens of Europe are tired of taking in and financing asylum seekers!
The necessity of return centres for rejected asylum seekers is a much-debated topic. Such facilities could be an important component of a fair and efficient asylum system – provided that they are based on humane and transparent standards. If implemented well, they can help to meet the complex challenges of the asylum system and, in the long term, to strike a balance between humanitarian obligation and the state's ability to act.