Zürcher Nachrichten - Court challenge begins against UK oil and gas field approvals

EUR -
AED 3.859481
AFN 71.756324
ALL 98.731551
AMD 410.573973
ANG 1.898343
AOA 958.299952
ARS 1057.5828
AUD 1.620305
AWG 1.891382
AZN 1.787514
BAM 1.965786
BBD 2.126704
BDT 125.86941
BGN 1.959578
BHD 0.396069
BIF 3111.577045
BMD 1.050768
BND 1.419397
BOB 7.30511
BRL 6.108936
BSD 1.053351
BTN 88.798959
BWP 14.389096
BYN 3.447011
BYR 20595.049833
BZD 2.123186
CAD 1.482918
CDF 3015.70356
CHF 0.930769
CLF 0.037175
CLP 1025.730425
CNY 7.626681
CNH 7.631617
COP 4607.354324
CRC 536.765442
CUC 1.050768
CUP 27.845348
CVE 110.825881
CZK 25.294035
DJF 187.56281
DKK 7.458928
DOP 63.475202
DZD 140.754561
EGP 52.127224
ERN 15.761518
ETB 131.339448
FJD 2.392545
FKP 0.829389
GBP 0.835949
GEL 2.868323
GGP 0.829389
GHS 16.589273
GIP 0.829389
GMD 74.604443
GNF 9077.02445
GTQ 8.133083
GYD 220.369466
HKD 8.177732
HNL 26.61696
HRK 7.495399
HTG 138.250992
HUF 410.051453
IDR 16731.48153
ILS 3.832965
IMP 0.829389
INR 88.571851
IQD 1379.809363
IRR 44224.189139
ISK 145.100113
JEP 0.829389
JMD 167.167612
JOD 0.745307
JPY 161.712177
KES 136.073015
KGS 91.195508
KHR 4227.434928
KMF 492.757542
KPW 945.690665
KRW 1469.37254
KWD 0.323384
KYD 0.877759
KZT 525.96186
LAK 23132.512015
LBP 94323.056453
LKR 306.507041
LRD 189.587683
LSL 19.044143
LTL 3.102644
LVL 0.635599
LYD 5.155188
MAD 10.582559
MDL 19.254813
MGA 4922.003534
MKD 61.670427
MMK 3412.852984
MNT 3570.509093
MOP 8.44098
MRU 41.88499
MUR 49.722097
MVR 16.234917
MWK 1826.47842
MXN 21.614084
MYR 4.693253
MZN 67.14173
NAD 19.044143
NGN 1768.579028
NIO 38.756512
NOK 11.690218
NPR 142.081414
NZD 1.79828
OMR 0.404533
PAB 1.053351
PEN 3.989366
PGK 4.24307
PHP 62.032083
PKR 292.554261
PLN 4.316456
PYG 8206.689576
QAR 3.842446
RON 4.977699
RSD 117.01459
RUB 110.961597
RWF 1438.192258
SAR 3.946062
SBD 8.816563
SCR 14.31215
SDG 632.036594
SEK 11.54187
SGD 1.415316
SHP 0.829389
SLE 23.854978
SLL 22034.081378
SOS 601.952158
SRD 37.295921
STD 21748.772974
SVC 9.216821
SYP 2640.085594
SZL 19.038716
THB 36.517315
TJS 11.227816
TMT 3.688195
TND 3.340977
TOP 2.461006
TRY 36.403794
TTD 7.154344
TWD 34.123163
TZS 2784.535199
UAH 43.712558
UGX 3902.826164
USD 1.050768
UYU 44.896792
UZS 13512.64356
VES 48.945141
VND 26707.891792
VUV 124.74927
WST 2.933314
XAF 659.299937
XAG 0.034685
XAU 0.000402
XCD 2.839753
XDR 0.805693
XOF 659.306243
XPF 119.331742
YER 262.61318
ZAR 19.049477
ZMK 9458.171236
ZMW 29.044545
ZWL 338.346819
  • CMSC

    0.0578

    24.73

    +0.23%

  • RBGPF

    0.8100

    61

    +1.33%

  • RELX

    -0.1800

    46.57

    -0.39%

  • VOD

    0.1800

    8.91

    +2.02%

  • NGG

    0.1500

    63.26

    +0.24%

  • AZN

    0.7700

    66.4

    +1.16%

  • RYCEF

    0.0200

    6.79

    +0.29%

  • GSK

    0.1900

    34.15

    +0.56%

  • RIO

    0.6300

    62.98

    +1%

  • JRI

    0.1600

    13.37

    +1.2%

  • BTI

    -0.0500

    37.33

    -0.13%

  • CMSD

    0.1200

    24.58

    +0.49%

  • SCS

    0.4500

    13.72

    +3.28%

  • BCE

    0.2500

    27.02

    +0.93%

  • BCC

    8.7200

    152.5

    +5.72%

  • BP

    -0.4000

    29.32

    -1.36%

Court challenge begins against UK oil and gas field approvals
Court challenge begins against UK oil and gas field approvals / Photo: Daniel LEAL - AFP

Court challenge begins against UK oil and gas field approvals

Two environmental groups kicked off a legal challenge in Scotland on Tuesday to block the Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields in the North Sea, with activists optimistic of success.

Text size:

"We're more confident than ever we can win," said environmental lawyer Tessa Khan before the case opened at the Court of Session in Edinburgh.

Her optimism was shared by hundreds of people who demonstrated outside the court, in celebratory mood given recent rulings that have put the future of the fields in doubt.

Campaign groups Uplift and Greenpeace argue that the UK government granted permissions unlawfully by failing to take into account all emissions from burning oil and gas.

A win for the campaigners would mean operators would have to resubmit environmental assessments for approval before drilling can start.

Former Scottish National Party lawmaker Tommy Sheppard called the case "the granddaddy because it is so big".

"The case will be applied to the decision-making process in general," he told AFP.

"There were 100 licences granted by the last Conservative government in its final dying months. All of them will now be under question."

Regulatory approval for drilling at the Rosebank oil field, 145 kilometres (90 miles) off the Shetland Islands in Scotland's far north, was granted last year.

It is the UK's largest untapped oil field, estimated to contain up to 300 million barrels. Drilling had been due to begin between 2026 and 2030.

The Jackdaw gas condensate field, approved in 2022, is being developed 155 miles east of the Scottish city of Aberdeen and was expected to start production next year.

Rosebank is owned by Norwegian energy giant Equinor and the UK's Ithaca Energy. Jackdaw is owned by Shell. Both say the developments are "vital" for UK energy security.

- Narrow window -

Khan, who is executive director of Uplift, said it had been a "David versus Goliath" battle at the start of the case, pitting campaigners on one side against the UK government and energy firms on the other.

But in July, the UK Supreme Court ruled that the previous Conservative government should have considered the carbon emissions of burning extracted oil and gas, not just of extracting it.

Then the incoming Labour government announced it would not contest the case, leaving the oil companies alone to fight legal challenges.

"We are on the precipice of a massive victory for the climate," said Uplift campaigner Lauren MacDonald.

Khan said there was a broader message to the oil industry: that they now have to take into account all greenhouse gas emissions, even those that occur indirectly.

"We now have a government that is really trying to re-establish the UK's climate credentials," she said. "The window for approval has really, really narrowed."

- Renewables -

Sheppard said the increased economic costs would force energy companies to look towards developing the renewables sector, provided the government gives the necessary investment and incentives.

At the same time, governments in oil-generating countries like Scotland must tread a fine line in balancing the longer term threats of rising temperatures with the shorter term risks of job losses in the sector.

Energy historian Ewan Gibbs, from the University of Glasgow, pointed to potential parallels with the breakdown of social cohesion caused by the closure of the UK's coal mines in the 1980s without a plan for those made redundant.

Prime Minister Keir Starmer, in Baku, Azerbaijan for the UN climate change summit, intends to decarbonise Britain's power grid by 2030 as part of government plans to reach net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

Sheppard said it was important that those affected by net-zero transition plans be reskilled and retrained to enable them to benefit from new jobs being created by clean energy technologies.

O.Pereira--NZN