Zürcher Nachrichten - A World Cup on three continents sparks climate concerns

EUR -
AED 3.833036
AFN 72.965693
ALL 98.471179
AMD 410.488288
ANG 1.873203
AOA 958.000963
ARS 1062.038807
AUD 1.66843
AWG 1.878434
AZN 1.766427
BAM 1.956221
BBD 2.098651
BDT 124.206714
BGN 1.955593
BHD 0.392184
BIF 3072.96093
BMD 1.043574
BND 1.411604
BOB 7.182545
BRL 6.351196
BSD 1.039424
BTN 88.365005
BWP 14.36609
BYN 3.401532
BYR 20454.059244
BZD 2.089349
CAD 1.499345
CDF 2995.05897
CHF 0.932946
CLF 0.037363
CLP 1030.951736
CNY 7.614337
CNH 7.609349
COP 4549.678541
CRC 524.41279
CUC 1.043574
CUP 27.654723
CVE 110.288721
CZK 25.122494
DJF 185.089809
DKK 7.459825
DOP 63.293613
DZD 140.679257
EGP 53.089735
ERN 15.653617
ETB 129.567767
FJD 2.418014
FKP 0.826492
GBP 0.830541
GEL 2.93199
GGP 0.826492
GHS 15.279286
GIP 0.826492
GMD 75.137432
GNF 8979.931397
GTQ 8.008723
GYD 217.45677
HKD 8.1152
HNL 26.384675
HRK 7.485461
HTG 135.979246
HUF 414.003677
IDR 16875.955523
ILS 3.804173
IMP 0.826492
INR 88.654261
IQD 1361.59285
IRR 43921.44146
ISK 145.182373
JEP 0.826492
JMD 162.624977
JOD 0.739996
JPY 163.239012
KES 134.188861
KGS 90.791231
KHR 4176.898364
KMF 486.43613
KPW 939.216423
KRW 1509.44706
KWD 0.321369
KYD 0.866186
KZT 545.867405
LAK 22749.89303
LBP 93077.018935
LKR 305.165635
LRD 188.650575
LSL 19.135816
LTL 3.081404
LVL 0.631248
LYD 5.107098
MAD 10.46095
MDL 19.145118
MGA 4904.05476
MKD 61.548238
MMK 3389.48911
MNT 3546.065849
MOP 8.32099
MRU 41.336891
MUR 49.25533
MVR 16.074375
MWK 1802.287635
MXN 20.948886
MYR 4.704445
MZN 66.688299
NAD 19.135816
NGN 1617.06
NIO 38.248226
NOK 11.818742
NPR 141.384409
NZD 1.847868
OMR 0.401566
PAB 1.039424
PEN 3.870432
PGK 4.214907
PHP 61.435071
PKR 289.313125
PLN 4.262104
PYG 8104.743162
QAR 3.789115
RON 4.979519
RSD 117.055686
RUB 107.251485
RWF 1448.911631
SAR 3.919987
SBD 8.748864
SCR 14.552642
SDG 627.709679
SEK 11.516721
SGD 1.41425
SHP 0.826492
SLE 23.790453
SLL 21883.237615
SOS 594.027763
SRD 36.661863
STD 21599.884172
SVC 9.094956
SYP 2622.01237
SZL 19.131115
THB 35.711018
TJS 11.370846
TMT 3.662946
TND 3.312012
TOP 2.444153
TRY 36.698543
TTD 7.054517
TWD 34.052871
TZS 2468.53093
UAH 43.591676
UGX 3812.820058
USD 1.043574
UYU 46.359971
UZS 13400.882252
VES 53.718256
VND 26564.187656
VUV 123.895249
WST 2.883175
XAF 656.098113
XAG 0.035368
XAU 0.000398
XCD 2.820312
XDR 0.792871
XOF 656.098113
XPF 119.331742
YER 261.284971
ZAR 19.072706
ZMK 9393.420989
ZMW 28.765187
ZWL 336.030548
  • RBGPF

    59.9600

    59.96

    +100%

  • NGG

    0.8200

    58.5

    +1.4%

  • RELX

    -0.3100

    45.47

    -0.68%

  • BCC

    -0.2600

    122.75

    -0.21%

  • BCE

    0.0500

    23.16

    +0.22%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    8.39

    +0.12%

  • SCS

    -0.5800

    11.74

    -4.94%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    7.27

    -0.14%

  • CMSC

    0.0200

    23.86

    +0.08%

  • RIO

    -0.0900

    58.64

    -0.15%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    23.56

    0%

  • GSK

    0.1700

    33.6

    +0.51%

  • BTI

    0.1131

    36.24

    +0.31%

  • AZN

    0.9100

    65.35

    +1.39%

  • JRI

    0.1100

    12.06

    +0.91%

  • BP

    0.1900

    28.6

    +0.66%

A World Cup on three continents sparks climate concerns
A World Cup on three continents sparks climate concerns / Photo: GABRIEL BOUYS - AFP/File

A World Cup on three continents sparks climate concerns

The 2030 FIFA World Cup will send dozens of football teams and hordes of fans crisscrossing the globe for matches on three continents, sparking alarm over the environmental cost.

Text size:

An announcement on the 2030 and 2034 World Cups will be made on Wednesday, with expectations of a dramatic expansion of geographic footprint -- and with that planet-heating greenhouse gas emissions.

While Saudi Arabia is the lone candidate for 2034, Morocco, Spain and Portugal have formed a joint bid for the 2030 tournament, with Uruguay, Argentina and Paraguay each also set to host a match.

Guillaume Gouze, of the Centre of Sports Law and Economics at the University of Limoges, said FIFA has a "moral responsibility" to integrate climate concerns into its tournament plans.

Instead, he said, it had proposed World Cups that are an "ecological aberration".

- 'Crazy idea' -

Benja Faecks of the NGO Carbon Market Watch, which evaluates climate promises of major events, told AFP that in general attempts at greenwashing in sport -- or "sportswashing" -- are harder than they used to be, with academics and campaigners holding organisations to account.

But she said that the 2030 tournament was "an unfortunate geographic choice".

When an event is spread over sites thousands of kilometres apart, teams and potentially hundreds of thousands of their loyal fans have to travel by plane.

The three matches in Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay are to mark the 100th anniversary of the event, which was born in Montevideo.

FIFA is keen to support access to football across different parts of the world, said David Gogishvili, a researcher at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland.

But "it is a crazy idea in terms of the impact this choice will have on the planet", he added.

FIFA has already expanded participation in the competition, which will see 48 teams take part in the 2026 edition -- held in Mexico, the United States and Canada -- compared to 32 in 2022.

This "is almost worse than the Cup on three continents," says Aurelien Francois, who teaches sports management at the University of Rouen in France.

More teams means more fans wanting to visit the venues, more capacity needed in the hotel and catering sector, and more waste, among other issues.

FIFA says that, with the exception of the games in Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay "for 101 games, the tournament will be played in a footprint of neighbouring countries in close geographic proximity and with extensive and well developed transport links and infrastructure".

Meanwhile, oil and gas giant Saudi Aramco became a major sponsor earlier this year in a controversial deal that runs through to 2027.

In October, an open letter from more than a hundred female professional footballers across 24 countries called for the deal to be cancelled on the grounds of human rights and environmental concerns, saying: "FIFA might as well pour oil on the pitch and set it alight".

- Fan zones -

Just shrinking the geographic footprint is not enough, researchers said.

While the 2022 World Cup was held in a "compact" site in Qatar, it was necessary to build new air-conditioned stadiums that were rarely reused.

Potential improvements could include a policy of not awarding the World Cup to a city where everything has yet to be built, echoing a rule by the International Olympic Committee, said Gogishvili.

Another idea to reduce air travel is to reserve a large proportion of stadium tickets for fans travelling from within a few hundred kilometres, and encourage transport by train.

Gouze, like other experts interviewed by AFP, supports creating more fan zones in soccer-loving cities for "a collective experience" that recreates the stadium atmosphere in front of a big screen.

But this would need FIFA to accept the impact on the economic profitability of the World Cup.

Soccer fans are a reflection of the population as a whole, so a growing percentage are more environmentally conscious than even a few years ago, said Ronan Evain of Hamburg-based Football Supporters Europe.

He said that while co-hosting is not a problem in and of itself, citing the example of the 2002 Cup co-hosted by Japan and South Korea, the 2030 tournament poses "too many questions" for fans.

These include the environmental costs, as well as financial considerations for fans trying to follow their teams across the planet.

But die-hard supporters will not let the long-haul flight put them off, said Antoine Miche, director of Football Ecologie France.

"Passion can make you do things that don't make sense," he added.

O.Krasniqi--NZN